News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nintendo Open Source Software Source Code Distribution Page by userbinator on Friday August 01, 2014 @11:46PM (#8123931)
But what exactly is a "link"? If I write e.g. a piece of software that enables combining and running arbitrary code from any library, GPL or otherwise (think of something like rundll32 on Windows), and use that instead, via parameters that the user somehow has to supply in order to get the right libraries and symbols, does that also become GPL? I can thus use any GPL (or otherwise) library in the same way that Xcode uses GCC.

This and other "how long is a piece of string" type of issues is why I think licensing is overall a horrible ridiculous convoluted mess.

Re:Nintendo Open Source Software Source Code Distribution Page by belorn on Saturday August 02, 2014 @12:13AM (#8123978)
Linking is simply a simplification of "what defines a derivative work" that FSF think helps developer. It is by no means final, and one can always hope that the court system will find the definition of derivative work at some other point.

I would however call it a bad bet to incorporate someone else code into a proprietary product, on the off chance that the general known line of "linking" can be invalided by the courts. The lack of case files should be a strong hint towards that.