News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by thetrumanshow on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @02:48PM (#811598)
>> The worse the disparity in income, the worse the economic mobility and the worse society is as a whole.

Maybe. Mining towns come to mind.

In general disparity in wealth is good, driving people to compete and innovate. However, as in the mining town example, there could be point at which the disparity in money/power becomes too great.

Edit: I intended to be referencing Company Towns (en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Company_town). Mining towns of the past are typically a good for-instance.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by astine on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:35PM (#811888)
The mining town problem is not a matter of wealth disparity but rather a Monopsony on labour. Only one party owns the mines (usually) and that party rules the town. Redistribution is not going to help in this case; though, splitting the mine among several owners might.
Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by david927 on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:01PM (#811631)
In general disparity in wealth is good

On what planet? Show me an example and I'll show you a thousand examples of how it's disastrous.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by amalcon on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:19PM (#811689)
The typical argument is that wealth is a good motivator. If a person's work improves the total lot of the world by quantity X, and it's distributed pseudorandomly, that's good. If the extra motivation helps them improve the total lot of the world by 2X, they keep 25% of that, and the rest is distributed pseudorandomly, that would seem to be better.

There are a lot of assumptions in there that some people don't like to talk about. Fairness of the pseudorandom function and other forms of motivation are obvious ones, but there are many more. It's still a credible argument for why disparity in wealth could possibly be a necessary consequence of something good. It's just not a credible argument that this is necessarily the case.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by silentbicycle on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:56PM (#811795)
> The typical argument is that wealth is a good motivator.

It can be a good demotivator when the disparity is large and hard work seems unrewarded, though - it can nurture a fatalistic outlook in which the rich are rich because the game is rigged, they "chose the right parents", etc., rather than working hard to get there. The rewards have to seem attainable.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by run4yourlives on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @05:28PM (#812013)
because the game is rigged

That's exactly what pg was referring to when he spoke of historical contexts and the controls other than the market in allocating wealth.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by amalcon on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @04:10PM (#811823)
Yes, that would be another example of an assumption: that the disparity does not grow large enough for this to be common. This one would seem particularly unfounded.
Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by david927 on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @04:26AM (#812749)
That's all paper and pencil thinking. I would humbly suggest looking out your window. By your same reasoning, the longer a person is unemployed, the more they would desire becoming employed and the more motivated they would become. The reality is the opposite: they become more and more defeated, they feel more and more hopeless.

There have been some very interesting studies done on this by a Stanford professor with children from the projects. (I'll look it up if you're interested.) The feeling of despair and hopelessness sets in very early.

I understand the theory you're presenting; however, I have found the opposite to occur in reality.

Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by amalcon on Wednesday September 09, 2009 @07:35PM (#814210)
It seems prudent to note that, though I described the theory, I do not subscribe to it. As I said, it's based on a lot of assumptions that its subscribers don't like to talk about, and most of them are not well founded assumptions.
Re:Mind the Gap (2004) by kiba on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @03:17PM (#811681)
Perhaps the distribution of wealth right now are more consituted by forces of harm by such as mininum wages law, unionism, corporate subsidy rather than forces of benefit.

Good forces may affect the outcome in several ways.

1. More uniform distribution of wealth as freedom to exchange and contract are unencumbered by politics.

2. More extreme variation as productivity are given higher improtance, and thus different level of prosperity among individuals.

3. Uber specialization leading to the rise of higher, real wages for everyone as it become more difficult to just throw poorly educated people at it.