This is something I don't understand. All the potholes are filled, all government buildings are perfectly clean, no new infrastructure projects can be productively performed? Productively working women already have free child care provided? The government is already doing everything we want it to do, and there is no use whatsoever for low skill labor?
I reckon people will become like you, working to improve the systems that support our infrastructure. Where the work of one provides for many. Where schooling isn't some odd prepping for ye old industrialization period but directly launching us into reinventing agriculture, energy grids, transportation, space exploration, production & knowledge. Where we will become not to a resource economy or a services economy. But a research, knowledge and engineering (automation) economy.
When everyone's expectations of conventional capitalism dies down. We will truly transform as a civilization.
Starbucks provides a startling example: making a coffee was automated a long time ago, but people still would rather have another person make their coffee. I'm pretty sure the same is true about hairdressers, stylists, nurses, personal trainers and glacier guides.
(Note: I'm not advocating a policy or direction, merely stating an observation)
You're probably right that this isn't the future we'll get. Just like that old prediction that the Radioisotope generator would power all electronics since it was the superior energy source at the time. Then Chernobyl hysteria changed our future. Probably just like some famous automated car crash that will likely occur. Or a neo-luddite media circus. Who knows what's gonna happen in 50 years.
I don't think automation means removing human interaction out of the picture. And I think people's desire for a person to do this work is going to subside as more interactions are personal instead of commercial. It'll free up us to do activities that are more creative, experimental & empathetic with each other. So if anything, it'd be redistributing human interaction into more social roles than compared to a face punching buttons and pulling levers.
The whole giving people in Retirement homes electronics animal things to cover the basic human requirement of physical touch and simulated bonding would become unnecessary (hopefully). Since families lifetimes wouldn't be devastated/adsorbed by trying to sustain your bodies physical requirements and running the financial treadmill optimized by bankers.
"I doubt we will all become engineers, scientists and technologists" We don't need to all become those things. But to orient our education in new ways to supports primarily these groups and the rest of people learn value creating activities that support each other & themselves. There will probably be some kind currently unimaginable creatives economy where large parts of society are centered around art and media.
Yeah this turned into a huge stupid rant. Time to sleep the stupid off.
For instance, automation of carpentry won't destroy carpentry as a skill. Because people like doing these things and when they aren't forced do it. As a wage as it's often a creative outlet. Many love their jobs as a hobby but it just becomes work for a wage. Then the hobby become a chore and no longer satisfying or valuable personal time investment. Especially if we start considering how little time we have on Earth.
This could be as significant as the step from Slavery to Workers. Except instead of soft-choice, this would put voluntarism as the center piece. Which would then lead to society's institutions being also based on charity/voluntarism.
I'm not saying the disadvantages outweigh the benefits of basic income. I'm undecided. But I'm also disappointed with how the risks are often brushed off.
My guess is that the majority of the people would do just like that, and while we would probably have more Linus like people who start building things by sheer curiosity, we would lose lots of industrial work and research, and I am not sure we would end up winning.
So I don't know. I am genuinely interested in the BIG, and think it could unleash the creativity of some people, but I am afraid the majority of us would just waste time into useless distractions. Maybe the BIG should last a given period (like one year), at the end of which it can be renewed if the beneficiary can prove that he or she has spent enough time on something "interesting" - it can be the kind of things you mention, something artistic, doing some studies, traveling, etc. The definition of "interesting" needs to be loose, but the beneficiary has to prove that he or she hasn't only been watching youtube and facebook.
Presuming that the time spent on youtube and facebook was not actually valuable (and I will quickly grant that there are ways to spend time on both that are not) I think this is part of a much larger issue we have with motivation and addictive/avoidant behavior. Push to "get a job" can help some people with this, but I think it's actually destructive to others; I think in general we need some better approach - which might be as simple as better mental health care (at the level of helping people meet their goals most effectively) but I'm open to ideas. I think this is needed whether we implement BIG or JG, or not.
So I don't think it's a clear cut situation that wage labour automatically means a good and productive society and that BIG means a bad and unproductive one.
I would say that the current productivity is quite low for the employed people, maybe 0.1 in average, and follows some kind of log-normal distribution (all of this are super rough approximation). If we adopt BIG, we would have lots of people who will have 0 productivity (maybe 95% of the population, much more IMHO), and the rest will have a higher productivity.
Would we be better off? It's not clear to me, especially at the beginning - maybe after one generation people will get used to work on what they really like - but I would really like to see some experimentation in that direction.
If I had a BIG the kinds of software I'd work on would be:
- Making self-hosting easy
- Making encrypted communications easy for anyone to use
- Mesh networking systems to diminish ISP dependency
- Simulations of ecosystems, including climate modelling
In other words I'd be able to work on things of real value rather than having to work on things of little value just to have basic needs met.