News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economics is not a natural science by davidw on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @06:43AM (#810651)
These sorts of comments are exactly why we flag economics articles here. There are plenty of people here that take exactly the opposite view (or views, depending on the degree to which they take those views) - that markets should be even more open/free/etc... On the other end, there's even some guy who says he's a "venture communist".

Economics is something that we can all agree to disagree on in order to talk about what we have in common: hacking and startups.

Re:Economics is not a natural science by christofd on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @08:58AM (#810843)
No, Economics is very much part of the picture. Economics is not philosophy or religion but optimization under conditions of scarcity. As long as we remain metrics driven there's nothing wrong with talking optimization.

My two cents.

Re:Economics is not a natural science by davidw on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @09:32AM (#810909)
The problem is that very tightly linked to that is "optimized for what?", and people and societies have different goals.

If people were ok simply talking about economics as a mechanism for optimization... that would be one thing, but these discussions pretty much always degrade on the internet.

Re:Economics is not a natural science by christofd on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @11:01AM (#811124)
Agreed, most of these discussions lack rigor.
Re:Economics is not a natural science by onreact-com on Tuesday September 08, 2009 @07:46AM (#810722)
I did not say that markets should be less free. Neither are they free nor is it desirable to return to some kind of soviet state capitalism (it was only called communism but the means of production never were it the hands of the workers which is the prerequisite of communism).

Nowadays the market is not free at all, it's ruled by a few oligopolies in most industries. You must be blind not to acknowledge that. The creation of corporations was the last nail in the coffin of the free market.

A market can only be free where all people can take part in it and not only a few decide who gets the money. Btw.: The abolitionists attempted to abolish wage slavery as well but it's still prevalent.

It's also absurd to sever the economics from the business and startups part. Also web programming in open source projects is just pure communism. So just saying we don't talk about economics here is like talking about cars without ever mentioning the engines.

Like with cars we have to rethink the way we build engines. With cars it's the hybrid/electric model, with capitalism it's something else. We just can't go on like that. The economy break down has just been postponed. It will happen sooner or later.

Ignoring or censoring that fact won't make it disappear.

To be honest: The current set up of startups begging a few VCs for money is neither sustainable nor does it make much sense. Just look at most startups. Either they disappear, they get swallowed and more or less left to rot or the VCs fire the founders. Or of course they go bankrupt. Is this what people are working for? I doubt that.

I guess sooner or later crowdfunding will take over and VCs will disappear. Maybe sooner than later as the financial system can finally break down any day.