Re:Why it makes sense to bike without a helmet
by sdrothrock on Wednesday July 30, 2014 @12:42AM
(#8106417)
I feel like being dead or brain damaged also reduces the overall quality of life.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Why it makes sense to bike without a helmet
by rflrob on Wednesday July 30, 2014 @01:02AM
(#8106474)
Of course it does. But presumably most people who bike will never have a potentially fatal brain injuring accident, while having a healthier, more environmentally friendly, cheaper life (gas is expensive!), and on balance, it's a net positive expected benefit, for some set of plausible weights of pros and cons.
Re:Why it makes sense to bike without a helmet
by nikisweeting on Wednesday July 30, 2014 @01:04AM
(#8106480)
Ah, but this is the tricky moral question, do we enact a law that may decrease a large population's quality of life significantly, or do we enact one that doesn't, but allows for the death of a few?
Arguably, the greater good is done by not enforcing helmet laws, because vastly more people will bike, and thus get more exercise, outweighing the few major accidents per year.
Re:Why it makes sense to bike without a helmet
by sdrothrock on Wednesday July 30, 2014 @01:08AM
(#8106495)
> do we enact a law that may decrease a large population's quality of life significantly
Before asking that question, I wonder how many people don't bike because of the helmet versus how many say that they don't bike because of the helmet but really would take any excuse.