The ultimate problem is that stock market returns are a future-prediction problem. When a stock does better than expected, it goes up. When it does worse than expected, it goes down. Doing this reliably includes both having a complete understanding of the rest of the market's expectations and knowledge of the future, which is pretty challenging.
I think that behavioral-finance approaches, which gauge the emotions of your fellow investors, have actually been shown to work pretty well. "Be fearful when others are greedy, and greedy when others are fearful." Hard to put that in an index, though.
I don't know, isn't that what the junk-bonds guys did in the '80s, and more recent value investors? I could believe that the market still undervalues companies that are about to go bankrupt (but might not).
In theory you can do better with fundamental-weighting (i.e. weighting by revenues, earnings, P/E, PEG, etc.), but there are a lot of subtleties to a stock's future performance that are not captured in the financials and are exploitable against an investor that only naively looks at them. You end up with an investor that's picking up companies that are looting their future prospects for cash because their market is disappearing.