I've never seen a startup where the founders knew everything they needed to at company formation. Usually it's one giant, steep learning curve.
But let's say you have some underlying quality, say intelligence or ambition or determination or "grit". This quality will probably correlate with success at both fundraising and building/running a company.
Now I don't have anywhere near the experience of YC or even you, but I wold imagine that at least intelligence and determination are positively correlated with both. So I'd expect someone who is good at fundraising to also be good at the rest.
There could be a few reasons why this might not be the case. It could be that we're looking at a small subset who have already passed an intelligence/determination threshold, above which these 2 traits matter less, and time spent developing the proper skills matters more. It could be that there are other factors in raising money or building/running companies which matter more, which would be an interesting conclusion to me.
Or it could be that I've made an error in reasoning somewhere :)
Now take two founders, one of whom is twice as effective at fundraising as the other. There are a couple possibilities: maybe he spent 7 weeks more time practicing fundraising than the other, or maybe he spent 6 weeks more and is 2 standard deviations more intelligent. If he spent 7 weeks more time practicing, then the other founder who devoted that to, say, customer development will know the market twice as well. But even if he spent 6 weeks practicing and gets a boost from his higher intelligence (equivalent to 1 week of practice), the other person is still 60% more effective at the other stuff.
This model is very much simplified, but illustrates a big point that I took a long time to learn: small broad-based improvements take much longer to pay off than targeted, high-% improvements in narrow areas. So yes, being intelligent is nice, it helps slant every skill you learn in your favor. But it is no substitute for actually practicing hard and removing errors.
There are similar counterintuitive principles at work in many other areas. I've found that engineering tools or frameworks that promise a few percent improvement in productivity are rarely worth learning and almost never worth developing unless they have a huge userbase, because it may take you 2 months to develop them but if they save you 5% in development time it'll take 40 months to break even, by which time they're probably not applicable anymore. Similarly, you are almost always better off hiring the person with little experience who is really passionate about your company, rather than the guy who is seemingly a genius at everything he does but really doesn't care about you or what you do. It's probably also behind the YC advice to be "narrow and deep" when building for customers; you can improve the product much more quickly when directly targeting a small userbase than when trying to please a large one.
My late grandfather was a master salesman. People would believe what he said, because he himself believed it when he said it. He was also amazingly good at knowing what people wanted to hear. What he wasn't so good at were trivial things like "facts" and "truth": those things often got in the way of believing the most useful thing at the moment.
Several times I've had pals at software companies where the CEO has great sales skills. Every time it's gone great at the beginning, because they get plenty of initial customers. But then things get ugly, because the CEO's promises aren't constrained by the realities of software development. It's death by a thousand cuts as tech debt mounts. Or key customers leave because the CEO consistently promises things that can't be delivered. Or some other ending where ugly reality eventually intrudes upon the CEO's beautiful vision.
I'm sure some people are great at raising money because they're great at building companies. But I'm equally sure that some people are great at raising money because they're terrible at running companies.
A company needs all kinds of complementary skills but in the beginning it only has whatever the founders can bring with them.
Let's put it this way - if someone is really good at sales, I'd think they're more likely to be good at general management, given enough time to learn that skill.
In the cases of companies, since the founder's job is usually to learn whatever skills are relevant for the current state of the company, and then execute those reasonably well, I'd expect the founder to learn the currently relevant skill of fundraising, then later to learn the currently relevant skill of managing a small startup, then later to learn the currently relevant skill of managing a larger company, etc.
1. There existed people who clearly were, in general, intelligent, hardworking people who completely and totally DID NOT GET computer science. It was frustrating dealing with them, because they were accustomed to the idea that if they put in effort, they mastered subjects -- but it wasn't happening for CS. At least, in a semester.
2. There were people who really "got" iterative programming but were completely flailing when it came to functional programming.
3. There were people who really "got" functional programming but were completely flailing when it came to iterative programming.
Now, on some level, I'm sure that there is an underlying general intelligent/merit thing going on. Nobody who got into my college was an idiot. I'm sure that even the people who were struggling were doing better than would a hypothetical person with a mental disability whose development never got past the 6-year-old level.
But it seemed clear to me that there is a measure of differential, narrow aptitude in the realm of computer programming, not just general aptitude. I would imagine that there is also narrow aptitude in sales, investing, running a company, etc.
Also, think about the time component. Even if your viewpoint were true, there isn't always time in a startup to become proficient in a skill you don't yet have. If it were that easy, startups would be a lot simpler.
Well, evidence to the contrary should persuade me. But isn't that pretty much the definition of IQ? A kind of "general intelligence quotient" which is broadly applicable to many different skills? E.g. I'd expect Stephen Hawking to be pretty good at chess if he ever decided to apply himself at it.
But, all other things being equal, I'd expect someone who's good at "winning" at the game called "raising money" to be the type of person who is better at winning at other games, e.g. running a good company. In other words, while being good at raising money doesn't necessarily mean they're good at running a company, I'd still take them over the "average person".
You seem to imply the opposite in your post - is that really right? Maybe people who are good at fundraising have spent too much time/energy on that vs. getting good at building a company? That sounds specious to me.