Let's say for a moment, for the sake of argument, that YC decided to be unethical and accept payment in exchange for "accepting" people to the program to get them a visa.
1) Would it be so terrible to have people who have enough money to afford such a bribe be in the US contributing to the economy?
2) Do you really think YC would stake their reputation on such an abuse?
3) O1A visas are often given to artists, actors and athletes. Do you think that there isn't at least a few theater and movie production houses (usually underfunded and desperate for cash) that are accepting the payments to list a rich foreigner as an "actor" in their show?
In other words, I don't think this is actually a huge concern.
The problem is that it still allows private individuals to profit by being gatekeepers to the country. Extracting unfavorable financing deals that wouldn't be tenable if the investor didn't also hold the founders' residency permits, extracting corporate governance concessions for the same reasons. The list goes on.
We've seen widespread abuse of the H1B visa when it comes to turning labor into near-indentured servitude, particularly around the green card process. There's no reason to believe that YC, or any of the high-profile players in the Silicon Valley Funding Party are above it.
> "1) Would it be so terrible to have people who have enough money to afford such a bribe be in the US contributing to the economy?"
Yes. There is an investment track immigration option for people who simply want to buy their way into the country - this money goes to fund all manners of things, instead of into private pockets of a hypothetically corrupt YC.
http://www.uscis.gov/green-card/green-card-through-job/green...
> "2) Do you really think YC would stake their reputation on such an abuse?"
Yes. Absolute power corrupts absolutely. If you give anyone the power to completely upend someone else's life at a whim, abuses will occur. Incentives are incredibly strong, and the slope is incredibly slippery. It will start with a gentle tilting of negotiations in favor of investors, and over years evolve into progressively more aggressive concessions.
At no point will anyone feel they are doing something overtly evil, just like how holding promotions back and lowering raises is just a matter of course when someone is in the midst of a green card application right now. It will all happen slowly enough that it won't feel like "abuse", it'll feel like "just the way things are".
> "3) O1A visas are often given to artists, actors and athletes. Do you think that there isn't at least a few theater and movie production houses (usually underfunded and desperate for cash) that are accepting the payments to list a rich foreigner as an "actor" in their show?""
Are we really making this argument? This boils down to "there is abuse happening elsewhere so we'll tolerate abuse here". Abuse of a system is abuse of a system - that it's happening elsewhere (possibly happening elsewhere I might add) doesn't justify it in our own back yard.
Letting private individuals gate-keep the country's citizenship/residency is a terrible, awful, stupid idea. It is a good idea only when predicated upon the assumption that the leaders of our industry are incorruptible.
Look at the Bay Area. Really look at the Bay Area. Is there any convincing evidence of the tech industry's incorruptibility?
Do you really think YC would stake their reputation
on such an abuse?
If they won't, Michaelt's Used Cars And Startup Incubator will accept any company with the application fee (2% preferred stock equity and $5000 per visa required).Or will the government get into ranking and evaluating incubators?
One thought was admissions rates, since folks seemed impressed by the soundbite that "YC had a lower admissions rate than Harvard," even leaving aside self-selection biases in the applicant pool.
Another is a startup community-run Self Regulatory Organization (SRO) that would get into the ranking and evaluating business a la Mattermark, with official certification/recognition by the government.
One thought was admissions rates
At Michaelt's Used Cars And Startup Incubator, $1000 of your application fees go on paying Mechanical Turk workers $1 a time to submit junk applications for immediate rejection :)But these were all details to be worked out over the next few weeks iff the WH was willing to move forward with these discussions. It's unclear if that's the case, unfortunately. So we might be discussing details that were never on the table for a broad proposal that has already been rejected on the political merits.
Exactly. More importantly in the incentive structure I foresee, do you think YC's LPs would allow YC to stake their reputation on such an abuse?
No, actually, this is incorrect. Those are O-1B visas, for the arts, not O-1A, which is business and science.
And the change was basically, here are the criteria as they currently stand. If we squint at the language, startup founders can successfully apply for this visa. But it's a torturous process, very variable in length of time, plenty of people don't apply.
Goal: regularize the preparatory process for founders so that it is repeatable and predictable.
Process: look at the existing criteria language, which is defined by statute and cannot be changed without passing a law. Suggest reinterpretations of that criteria language such that within existing law, founders whose startups are demonstrating metrics of success understood within our community can use those metrics to also successfully apply for a visa.
Right now, there are eight criteria to qualify for the O-1A, of which, an applicant needs to establish three of those criteria qualifications. About half are clearly directly intended for academics, aka "where has your research been published?"
One change proposed is that high signal accelerators be seen as prestigious associations, traditionally including late-career honors, e.g. IEEE lifetime achievement. Yet YC has an acceptance rate lower than Harvard (a gameable metric to be sure). It's incredibly competitive. Yet completely unknown within DC as such an honor. Or TechStars; or 500Startups. But the predictable question from DC is where to draw that line? And our response should be to figure out how to generalize investor/accelerator signal strength such that DC can use it for establishing visa qualifications.
But hopefully to assuage your concerns, no YC acceptance doesn't become a singular criterion for getting the visa. Though if accepted, the changes would see YC/500/TS/similar acceptance as one of three criteria needed to qualify for the O-1A.
And over time, I would certainly expect AngelList, Mattermark, Disruption, &c... to be valuable for establishing investor signal metrics to complement the "accelerator as educational institute" model that the regulatory proposal alludes to.
Finally, keep in mind that the startup visa legislative proposal involved funding levels (lower than YC or most other seed-level funding rounds) and jobs created (usually directly proportional to funding). So investors would still see a conflicts of interest there. It has been something I've grappled with in years of pushing startup visa. Do you have any proposed solutions or improvements over either the legislative model or this proposed regulatory change?
I've considered a semi-independent Self Regulating Organization (SRO), like the financial sector has with FINRA. But that's so anti-lean, there has never seemed to be much support within the investor community, leaving aside the massive turnover of startups. But theoretically, it'd be a group that removes YC or similar from the direct equation by recognizing prestigious investors or accelerator programs. You'd ask for folks like Naval Ravikant (or Kevin Laws) to serve on the board and recuse themselves where they're LP'd or do (significant?) along-side investment (or maybe simply investment at a similar level of startup development, i.e. seed, A, B, &c...).
Is the proposal really that YC acceptance becomes a singular criteria for getting the visa? So YC and their peers, in effect, would have full power to grant unlimited visas to people of their choice?
If that is what is being proposed, that sounds like a massive conflict of interest, with potential for serious abuse, even if the intent is positive.