Every seller is matched by a buyer at the same price!
I think you are making claims without thinking them all the way through. Let's go through an example:
Imagine there is a company with 1,000 shares. Alice buys a share from Bob for $100. This trade implicitly values the company at $100,000. Later, Carol buys a share from Dave for $50. This new trade implicitly values the company at $50,000.
The value of the company fluctuated by $50,000, but if you look at every trade, an equal number of dollars and shares were exchanged on each side. Alice lost $100 of money while Bob gained $100 of money. Carol lost $50 of money while Dave gained $50 of money.
No money "came out" of the stock.
The aggregate stock ownership stayed the same: 1,000 shares were owned both before and after.
The aggregate money supply stayed the same: $150 were in people's pockets both before and after.
The only thing that changed was the market consensus of the price of the company. The bottom line is that price changes of an asset class don't mean money is being soaked or released. Individual ownership can change, but aggregate ownership cannot.
Does that sound reasonable? I hope this conversation is helpful for people reading this comment thread.
Edit to add: My point is that the total value of the stock market fluctuates over time. If every sale is zero-sum, how are such fluctuations possible?
I think what often links stock prices with demand for money is risk preferences. If stocks become more volatile (which they tend to do while falling), investors deleverage. This deleveraging reduces the velocity of money and thereby increases the demand for cash. If unchecked, this will cause deflation and requires the Fed to create more money in response.