This mainframe strategy for IBM will keep many of their legacy customers, but as Cringley and others point out, it fails to capture new growth.
- move on to cloud technology or other newer technologies to stay relavent
- don't want to move back to mainframe since they see less jobs for them
- there are almost no junior level candidates for mainframe roles. Most candidates will have 10-20+ years of experience. It's extremely rare to find anyone less than 5.
It is true that legacy systems aren't going anywhere anytime soon. But as time goes on there's a high cost in finding people that can maintain those systems.
Further, a big chunk of IBM's server business is running its own Unix. That market is also in decline, and easier to switch away from. See http://www.itjungle.com/tfh/tfh030314-story06.html
So, I don't know about the last few years, but I think IBM can ride the mainframe money train for years to come. My point was simply that it's not going to drive any growth.
IBM used to be able to charge $1 million just to install its top-level mainframe OS (before rental charges) and C cost $1,500 a day. I expect those days have gone ;-)
One way Google kicked the ass of their competition was to radically their cost of computing through smart use of commodity hardware. It seemed like a small thing, but it gave them a lasting advantage, because nobody could afford to deliver the same search features.
Given IBM's deep pockets and deep experience with hardware, I'd think there must be some strategy there that would let them create cloud computing infrastructure with radically lower cost than the competition. We regular people are stuck with off-the-shelf colocation setups, off-the-shelf hardware, off-the-shelf processors, and off-the-shelf software. IBM can afford to change any of that from scratch. Any of it.
I just can't believe that, less than 10 years into the cloud computing era, we have already happened upon the optimum approach.
IBM has been the high-cost supplier for almost 100 years, so the idea that it will out-innovate and undercut Amazon, Microsoft and Google in the cloud is an interesting one. Especially as both Microsoft and Google have much deeper pockets and are approaching IBM in annual turnover. (IBM used to have 70% of the IT business. Fairly soon, it won't even be in the top 5.)
That's not the same as doing removing every other light bulb in the building (which is what Lucent did at Bell-Labs!)
You can scale up to a huge extent just with average x86 servers now and these are competing with what used to be done on a mainframe. So even many companies who don't or can't use distributed systems don't need to use IBM any more.
Consider Hadoop. I know of at two major DB2 customer who are investing in Hadoop rather than expanding their DB2 capabilities to handle problems IBM would love to solve with their solutions.
But it overlooks a core problem that IBM faces. The cloud is a competitive platform for problems that previously required mainframes. They successfully defended (kinda) against Oracle/Sun in areas like running large banks and stock exchanges.
What happens to IBM when you can solve hard real-time transaction problems on 1000 loosely-coupled distributed computers instead of 1 large mainframe (made up of a 1000 processors with shared state)? That day is either here or close.
My take is that they can't ignore the cloud but they can't win it either. Tough place to be.