Much of this internet privacy backlash is aimed specifically at Google and Facebook (and of course the NSA, but let's assume that they don't have any problems getting to your medical data anyway).
But then even if they weren't anonymized, I think Google would be one of the company I would trust the most for that. They know what they're doing in terms of security and of all the companies that know a lot about me, they're the one who consistently delivered great value from the data they have. I'm thinking of things like search, Google Now and the maps interface for my location history. Plus I'm happy that the monetization of my data serves to fund great projects like this one. It didn't have to be so...
Health data is very far from this idealized anonimization-friendly case. It is some of the most specific data avalible about you, and it can easily be abused to disadvantage you in ways you can do nothing about (insurance, job prospects, social standing, even as far as getting your life threatened by people who disagree with things like sexuality and abortion)
Im sure Google appreciates your faith in them. But you should carefully consider the consequnces. Once the information is out there, there is no getting it back.
[1] Although Google's direction is arguably more stable than is usual for publicly traded companies, given the particular share structure designed to keep control in the hands of the founders.
[2] Mostly, being in generally good health and living in a country where basic health insurance is guaranteed and good enough, with premiums that don't depend on your health.
The only way you can properly anonymize such data is by reducing it to aggregates but then most of the utility is lost.
Taking the combination of google search data and medical data it would not at all be hard to tie some of the searches (and thus identified users) to medical records. Especially not if the diseases / symptoms are rare.
Researcher should be forced to follow ethical guidelines in order to prevent data mining that try to unearth facts written between the lines, like sexual orientation. Patients should also be asked if the journal can be shared with researchers, in similar fashion as asking patients if they will accept to have an intern in the room. Last, there need to be some liability if journals get leaked. It is very important to create economic incentives for functional security, which experts are paid to regularly verify and test.
This has of course nothing to do with keeping large databases about people and selling it as a service or product. Nothing at all about Google business model.
As for medical records, no institution hoarding them has any interest in sharing them. Patients are not consulted on this, so their privacy is only a tiny part of the reason. As far as patient privacy goes, “anonymising” them is not so easy either, as another commenter already explained.
EDIT: Seriously, if the yardstick is "but but but think of all the great things we could do, just like we have with the internet" I'm going to request proof that we've in fact accomplished that tremendous good in terms of advertising and whatnot.
If they can't even show that for their main line of business, any claims about medicine seem shaky, no?
I say, wouldn't it be amazing if everyone's medical records were available anonymously to research doctors? And when someone accesses your medical record, a research doctor, they could see, you could see which doctor accessed it and why, and you could maybe learn about what conditions you have. I think if we just did that, we'd save 100,000 lives this year.
So I guess I'm just very worried that with Internet privacy, we're doing the same thing we're doing with medical records, is we're throwing out the baby with the bathwater, and we're not really thinking about the tremendous good that can come from people sharing information with the right people in the right ways.
Source: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mArrNRWQEso&t=839 at 14:00.