News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by fpgeek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @07:28PM (#8082944)
I wonder how EU regulators are going to react when, for example, Russian regulators demand that Google remove all links to "inaccurate" (i.e. not Russian propaganda) stories about MH17, worldwide.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @07:32PM (#8082966)
It's a fairly natural privacy issue. The EU DPD has some fairly clear rules about automated gathering of information about people, the rules under which you are required to honor requests for reports about that data, to update it if so required and to be deleted at the first request.

Google is side-stepping the reach of the EU by keeping the data on servers outside of the EU but this goes against the spirit of those laws, it is about the citizens not about where the data resides.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by shakethemonkey on Thursday July 24, 2014 @07:53PM (#8083035)
It's not so much against the spirit of those laws, but an attempt by the EU to apply its laws outside the jurisdiction of the sphere of absurdity that is the EU.

This is not at all about "where the data resides", as you claim, because the EU is not attacking the data where it resides -- it leaves that alone, on their original servers -- but instead where the data is indexed.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by fpgeek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:00PM (#8083069)
Yes, keeping the information available where the EU's jurisdiction doesn't reach subverts the spirit of the EU's laws, but what alternative is there? By that standard, even delivering censored results to all EU IP addresses isn't enough - that's trivially circumvented with a VPN. And if the EU gets to have the spirit of their laws reach worldwide, then so does every other government.

But that way lies madness. Once Google is done censoring every search result that any government objects to (including results governments let their citizens object to), what will be left?

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:13PM (#8083120)
The alternative is pretty simple: google should honour the requests of EU citizens to be forgotten by google, not a limited subset of google.

It's like the copyright battles in reverse, only this time the rights holders are citizens, and it is google playing shell games rather than say allofmp3.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jim-greer on Thursday July 24, 2014 @07:56PM (#8083057)
Thailand can just as easily say that laws banning criticism of the king are about the king, not where the data resides.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:05PM (#8083091)
They could indeed. And if Google had a Thai presence (I don't know if they do) and plan on keeping it then they should probably comply. Pesky problem, nation states that claim they trump corporations.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jim-greer on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:14PM (#8083125)
Here's a partial list of removal requests Google has gotten from governments. Are you saying Google should remove all of this worldwide?

http://www.google.com/transparencyreport/removals/government...

Or maybe you think it should only honor requests from these countries, where it has an office?

http://www.google.com/about/company/facts/locations/

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:17PM (#8083139)
Those requests have nothing to do with the right to be forgotten under the DPD. Really, censorship and privacy are two totally different issues and the mixture here is not conducive to progress.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by fpgeek on Thursday July 24, 2014 @11:28PM (#8083634)
This is nonsense. Google isn't making policy decisions about censorship and privacy, nor should they be. Instead, they're assessing when it is and isn't legally risky / expensive to return search result X to a user in country Y. At that level, privacy requirements and censorship requirements are functionally identical.

Just because the EU's legal restrictions are grounded in privacy doesn't mean another jurisdiction's won't be grounded in censorship. Which is one thing if those restrictions apply to search results intended for that jurisdiction and quite another if those restrictions are applied worldwide.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Friday July 25, 2014 @03:24AM (#8084103)
You are still reasoning from Google's viewpoint. There are other viewpoints. Such as citizens of the EU, who have decided to empower the EU with laying down laws dictating what companies can do with their data. If google wishes to continue to operate in Europe then it will have to comply with the law of the land.

Whether that is functionally identical with censorship or not is another debate.

We can have that debate, but it will end in some gray area where a convicted criminal that has served his sentence should probably be able to clear his name in the search engines and where a politician that was caught in some scandal will not be able to do the same (because he was a public figure at the time).

Censorship requests can simply be stonewalled until the company is sued and then the judges can side with Google or the claimant on a case-by-case basis.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by fpgeek on Friday July 25, 2014 @07:00AM (#8084575)
Frankly, the only perspective I care about in this mess is mine - that of a non-EU Google user. I'm only reasoning from Google's because I want to understand how these EU regulations are likely to impact me. Now that EU regulators are making it clear they won't be satisified by compliance tailored to their jurisdiction, it's clear that they will. Which is just wrong.

There's no sensible reason for EU regulations to have anything to do with the search results that I (as a non-EU citizen, searching from outside the EU, most likely using entirely non-EU servers, network connections and so on) see. I agree that the EU has the economic and political power to impose these regulations (on Google, Bing, Yahoo, ...). I just think that, even though they can, they shouldn't.

This is exactly the same sort of extraterritorial bullshit that drives the EU (and EU citizens) nuts when the US does it. See, for example, the US government demanding, from Microsoft, the emails of EU citizens stored on EU servers in response to a US search warrant. Or the volumes of requirements (tax monitoring, sanctions compliance and so on) the US imposes on non-US banks even when their only US connection is they sometimes transfer dollars between non-US customers.

EU citizens and EU regulators might care deeply about the "right to be forgotten", but if they think that endorsing and emulating the US's extraterritorial grandstanding in its name is going to be anything but a gigantic net loss for European privacy, they're kidding themselves, at best. Google's response to the "right to be forgotten" has been disappointing and frustrating (though I doubt we'd agree on why). What similarly powerful governments (e.g. US, China, ...) end up doing with the new tools the EU is forging to enforce that right will be terrifying.

[deleted]
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:31PM (#8083182)
> thefreeman

> It is EXACTLY the same thing.

Of course it isn't. Let me spell it out:

Censorship: A nation-state determining what its own populace can read about general world affairs and affairs concerning that governments own actions, inspection and possible redaction of communications between citizens and their access to media (such as books).

Privacy: The right of an individual to govern the whereabouts of the data concerning that particular individual.

You can't possibly confuse the two.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by mindrag on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:24PM (#8083162)
Pesky problem, civil liberties that apply to all people regardless of the whims of the government or the majority of its citizens. Free speech is guaranteed by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by jacquesm on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:39PM (#8083212)
Note that the concept of 'free speech' the way it is practiced in the United States is not present in EU law.

Arguing that freedom of speech trumps your privacy rights is a rather twisted interpretation of the UDHR, by that interpretation we have no privacy at all, because after all, anything, once uttered by another person immediately becomes 'free speech'.

Your life belongs to you, and so does the data about you, unless you choose to become a public figure (for instance by seeking public office), or you become one through circumstance (for instance because you crash a cruise ship into a rock and capsize it).

In those cases your right to be forgotten is going to be trumped by the rights of the public to be informed.

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by Vik1ng on Thursday July 24, 2014 @08:40PM (#8083214)

    Free speech is guaranteed by the Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
And pretty much every European as well as the US has put some limits to it.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_free_speech_exce...

Re:Google under fire from regulators on EU privacy ruling by ASneakyFox on Friday July 25, 2014 @04:36AM (#8084237)
The issue is not data location. Its that their localized domain for europe does but their international domain does not. Googles argument is their international domain doesn't fall under european jurisdiction.