Re:Writing a DSL with Python
by rw on Sunday September 06, 2009 @07:18PM
(#808285)
If you give something a name, yet still only use it once, what's the point? It is just semantic clutter to do that (unless, of course, you can't use multiline lambdas...).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
There is no big harm in giving something a name. Giving a name also helps if you find a need to reuse it later. Plus a name can give a hint to what this code is for.
Yet, if you look in functional programming code (e.g. Haskell, Scheme), you'll find many anonymous lambdas (that in python would be > 1 line). Why would good coders bother doing that?
If something is small and enough to be anonymous, it's usually simply enough to be expressed without binding a variable.
(See point-free style.)
Obviously. Show us how to do point-free style in Python. We're talking about Python's lame implementation of anonymous functions, not something that it doesn't have any implementation of.
Oh, I thought you were talking about programmers' habits in Haskell.
Re:Writing a DSL with Python
by GeneralMaximus on Sunday September 06, 2009 @10:41PM
(#808486)
In Python, you can easily define methods within methods, so there is little semantic clutter at the toplevel.
def doSomething():
def doSomethingElse():
# Code goes here.
pass
eggs = filter(doSomethingElse, spam)
for cheese in eggs:
# Do something.
pass