If you made it easy for me to upload my bill every month and made it transparent how the data was being scraped, I would totally do it. In fact, it would be a pleasure to make a small contribution to genuine competition.
The telcos would sooner or later try to thwart it, but that would draw attention to the whole endeavour.
That's what I had in mind when I wrote my article.
There are two viable approaches. The simplest one is to ask questions about the current or planned usage, and provide the best plans accordingly.
The second, more complex, one would be to allow a person to upload their phone bill, parse it, analyze it and determine the most advantageous plan(s) according to their usage patterns.
This is the most complex option because ideally it should allow for some flexibility in terms of handling bills from different carriers, entirely stripping the personal data (e.g., not even storing it somewhere on the server), and so on. However, it's also the sleekest and easiest one from the user's perspective.
It would be neat to offer both versions, this way a user could decide which method they prefer. And from an implementation standpoint, it would make sense to release the first method first, and then add uploading capabilities at a later stage.
Another challenge for the project will be ensuring that the data for the plans are up to date, but a solid effort in this regard and a good disclaimer should be enough to make a service like this useful, honest and (hopefully) lawsuit proof.
It sometimes feels like the Canadian version of the vi-vs-emacs debate is Bell-vs-Rogers - specifically, which one is more evil.
I would welcome any way to even the playing field a bit. If that involves sharing my bill - I'm happy to do it. I'm sure I wouldn't be the only one.
http://www.consumeraction.gov/resprt2.shtml
Without a doubt, each group has an agenda, so you have to be careful. Some are lefty, some are just industry fronts, and they all have an inevitable interest in increasing their own power and budget. But how is that any worse than the government? At least this way you aren't at the mercy of whatever power is temporarily in national ascendance. You can pick a group that reflects your own ideals. Maybe Canadian citizens should join Consumer's Union or a similar Canadian group and lobby them to produce the cell phone calculator with their own funds.
Now that government appears to have bowed out of the market niche, there's a possibility that private efforts might move forward. Of you're a Canadian with entrepreneurial spirit of your own, maybe you should look into making something like this happen before someone beats you to it (or even before some major telco manages to create a biased version of this and manages to convince people it's objective "enough").
It isn't. But the idea that telcos lobby elected officials to stop such an initiative doesn't speak well for these companies nor our representatives.
1. Government won't get its fingers into something it should (have to) do, and thus won't spend tax money unnecessarily.
2. You have more ways to evaluate the corruption and dishonesty of specific representatives and corporations.
It's not like the corruption didn't exist before you found out about it, after all.
Choosing a phone/carrier/plan in Canada is a significant pain point. If a simple, comprehensive, and accurate tool like this existed, it would likely become quite popular (if one does exist, I want to know about it!)
The biggest challenge - other than design - is making sure the pricing data is complete and up to date. I'm not sure how the government project planned to deal with this - whether they expected the carriers to cooperate (hah!), or whether they were planning to hire people to maintain the data from publicly available sources.
Either way, with the right structure, this could be a great project to crowdsource. The only similar things I've seen use a blog or forum structure.