It's commonly asserted that ideas are worth next to nothing, the difficulty is all in the execution, etc. I don't think that's entirely true. If your idea is just a vague one-liner like "facebook for pets", then sure, it's not worth much. But as you start building out a prototype, you're forced to be more specific and refine the idea, and it becomes more valuable. If you've got a handful of users and you've gotten some feedback, that's yet a bit more value. And if you've thought about the problem for a long time, you will probably have a good sense of what are the main challenges and what approaches won't work. That's valuable too.
I don't think there is a well-defined line between refining your idea and "executing" on it. Obviously there is a limit to how much you can accomplish in the planning and prototyping stage. However, I suspect it is a lot higher than is commonly believed. Working for 3 months may sound like not very much on the scale of a startup's lifetime (let's say 2-5 years before it either fails or grows big), but consider this: maybe the OP did 4 or 5 failed 3-month projects before he or she got to this one, which seems somewhat promising. Suddenly that looks a lot more significant than 3 months.
For this specific case, we don't have enough details to assess whether the OP has really hit on something big, or if there is still a lot of uncertainty about whether the idea will pan out. So unfortunately, after all that discussion, I don't really have an answer to the original question. I think what I would do in your situation is to make my best guess as to the "fair split" based on what I've contributed and the expected future value (let's say I decide it's 70/30), offer the friend that split, and if he/she accepts, I would immediately change it to 65/35. That way, they should be happy, but things are still close to fair from my perspective.
This is a very important point you make. I guess the exact dividing line between an idea that's worth something and an idea that's worth nothing is whether time or money has been invested into the idea or other forms of personal risk by the time it was just an idea. It is the investment and commitment that makes an idea valuable, not the idea itself.
This is something I tried to suggest to my former cofounder. His contribution was merely financial, and he wanted an exorbitant share of equity plus the title of CEO. I tried negotiating with him, but somewhere in the course of it I realized he was not the right person for any startup, and the venture was bound to fail with him onboard. I resigned and now have a startup that is quickly growing with loads of customers.
With regards to documentation of loans to company and things like that is having it recorded as a company liability (to the named entrepreneur) in the accounts sufficient or was it more formal than that?
For example, my LLCs have 10 million shares issued at par value 1/100th of a cent each. I own them outright. If for some reason I wanted to do a vesting agreement, I'd agree to the company having the option to purchase up to XYZ shares from me at par, with XYZ being any number up to and including the number defined by $VESTING_FORMULA_GOES_HERE.
With regards to documentation of loans to company and things like that is having it recorded as a company liability (to the named entrepreneur) in the accounts sufficient or was it more formal than that?
I figure as long as you're going to write it in the books of the company you might as well write a piece of paper saying
"$COMPANY agrees to, at a date of its choosing within 10 years of the inception of this agreement, repay to $FOUNDER the sum of $SUM plus 5.0% annualized interest." Sign twice (once in personal capacity, once as authorized representative of company), date, file for later.
Cliffs are, of course, negotiable. If someone suggested one to me with regards to my business, I'd accept it contingent on the clock starting at either launch or incorporation, either of which would result in the cliff being moot.
This gets very complicated very quickly. That's why you should consult lawyers (or legal documents available online, but unless you're a lawyers you should consult one anyway).
I'm actually not sure how this gets resolved in most startups. Oftentimes there are clauses like Shotgun clauses that try to solve this in a catch-all manner, providing a way of forcing people to sell their shares.
Also, being new to this, excuse my ignorance, what does vesting prevent? what does it encourage? First things that come to mind is if there were to be a fall out, the equity would remain under the one who stayed. On the opposite side, it encourages a long term commitment?
However, if you "loan" the company $4,500 to pay a designer for something, it absolutely owes you that money back.
I'd be inclined to have the company write you an IOU for your cash contributions so far, and split it 50/50, perhaps with one of you getting a tie-breaking share. The company can dispose of your IOU like any other short-term debt of the company at some point in the future when it has the financial wherewithal to do so. [See below about IOUs.] Your vesting clock starts 3 months ago, your partner's starts as of the day when he becomes full-time.
I cannot emphasize enough that your equity split is not nearly as important as "Does bringing this guy on uniquely make this business successful and do I have confidence that we will both be happy with this arrangement 5 years from now?"
Edit to add: As I get older and wiser, I am coming to appreciate the discipline of separating one's personal and business finances and explicitly receiving written acknowledgment for transfers of money into one's company. These feel like moving money from one pocket to another in the early days, but they are not, and explicit written confirmation of that fact will make your life easier in a lot of futures.
For example, I know one entrepreneur who, like many, tightened his belt, ran up substantial personal debt, and put blood sweat and tears into building a company. Professional money came into the company. Without documentation that he had loaned the company money, the best resolution would have been asking the other stakeholders to approve increasing his salary so that he could cover his "personal" debts. Had that documentation existed, he would have had ample authority to extinguish that debt in the ordinary course of business, and it would have likely had favorable personal tax consequences.