News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by incision on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:06PM (#8075895)
Am I missing something?

It seems to me the best thing this guy and the people who want to 'help' him could have done is just leave the whole thing alone.

On its own this is just another in an endless string of 'One weird fact this amazing kid discovered!' stories that will be forgotten next week if not tomorrow - like the ink saving science fair kid from March [1].

People who matter will find this guy and his discovery through the paper [2] he published. People reading the viral sources of the story about this girl and 'her discovery' will forget it all in the time it takes to click on through to '10 Celebrities Who Look Like Their Pets!'.

Also, the real problem here seems to be plain old bad/breathless media coverage more than anything else.

1: http://www.cnn.com/2014/03/27/living/student-money-saving-ty...

2: http://absci.fiu.edu/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/Jud-and-Laym...

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by jjoonathan on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:51PM (#8076205)
Yes, you are missing something: the narrative that the kid made a scientific discovery is spreading so far and wide that it could very plausibly become a PR/SEO problem for the grad student who is on the verge of launching his scientific career (the single time that this sort of thing matters most to a scientist).

> there is now a petition online demanding that Arrington’s name be added as an author to Jud’s most recent scientific publication

This goes far beyond "one wierd fact" headlines. Authorship requests and articles published in scientific venues (CFLAS) bring this issue into the scope of things that academics care about.

People who 1: matter and 2: have time will not be fooled. #2 is the sticking point. There are many gatekeepers to prestige in the academic world (journals, conference hosts, departments inviting each other around for guest lectures, people running outreach programs, etc). Many of them don't have the time or the inclination to get to the bottom of PR scandals. The ones that do have the time (e.g. hiring committees) pay attention to metrics representing the opinions of those who don't have time, so ignoring the problem won't make it go away.

He is doing the very minimum required to avoid being hurt by someone else's lie. The way I see it, he has handled the issue with admirable delicacy.

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by incision on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:25PM (#8076418)
>'This goes far beyond "one wierd fact" headlines. Authorship requests and articles published in scientific venues (CFLAS) bring this issue into the scope of things that academics care about.'

Not really.

Worrying about one of thousands if not millions of online petitions [1] that anyone can create is on par with fretting over whatever foolishness someone publishes on their blog.

There are a lot of people quoting and re-quoting that petition claim with anger and horror but there's not a single link to it and Google uncovers nothing.

I would not surprise me if such a petition exists, but whether it matters at all is highly questionable.

>'Many of them don't have the time or the inclination to get to the bottom of PR scandals.'

What scandal? The story of the girl will/would be forgotten tomorrow. It only becomes anything resembling scandal Streisand style as a result of the response [2].

1: https://petitions.whitehouse.gov/petition/outlaw-offending-p...

2: http://www.usatoday.com/story/tech/2014/07/23/marine-biologi...

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by jjoonathan on Thursday July 24, 2014 @05:41PM (#8082436)
> Not really.

Yes, really. Competition in academia is fierce. Professorship positions typically have dozens to hundreds of applicants each -- and all of those applicants have made significant contributions to a field of research (PhD) and then some (postdoc). Non-academic qualifications such as outreach, teaching evaluations, and so on are an important dimension along which aspiring academics can differentiate themselves.

> What scandal?

If the girl helped put together the paper and wasn't listed as an author, that would be a scandal. If you search Jud's name on google and a petition to add someone to one of his papers pops up, even the most rational person would assign a nonzero probability to the possibility that he did, in fact, wrong her. It is a SEO/PR problem.

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by gph on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:18PM (#8075977)
>Am I missing something?

Yes, integrity.

The easy thing probably would have been to leave this whole thing alone. But the easy thing to do isn't automatically the right thing to do.

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by incision on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:42PM (#8076151)
>'Yes, integrity.'

I'm confused, do you mean to be so needlessly insulting?

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by gph on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:41PM (#8076516)
You misunderstand, I'm not saying you personally lack integrity. I'm saying integrity is what is missing from your consideration of this issue.

Integrity and honesty are important values that are worth standing for even if it's not the most pragmatic course of action.

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by lotharbot on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @03:20PM (#8076388)
> "Am I missing something?"

Possibly that some people are accusing the grad student, who actually did the original research, as plagiarizing the little girl.

Neither she nor her father have, to my knowledge, corrected those critics.

Re:Sixth grader's internet-famous science project may have b... by jmount on Wednesday July 23, 2014 @02:16PM (#8075961)
The original researcher spoke out and complained, so I it is safe to assume they to some degree consider discussing this helpful.