I agree with you - it's rare to see this abused these days. Though I remember a particular nasty case from my childhood - a man in Oslo was committed with a diagnosis of paranoid delusions in 1971 after having been involved in a political struggle related to a school closure. His claims about violations of various laws in the process intended to close down the school were used as evidence of his supposed delusions. He was not released from the hospital until 1985. At which point he refused to leave the hospital, and camped outside it until near his death in 1996, while campaigning to have his diagnosis reversed.
The utterly bizarre situation was that he insisted that if the diagnosis stood, then he should be admitted, but the hospital refused - claiming he was too well to be admitted even voluntarily, while still insisting he still suffered from paranoid delusions.
In 1988 an investigation indicated that he was likely sane when admitted, though he may at some point later have suffered from mental problems caused or exacerbated by his forced hospitalisation.
In 1995 the relevant government department gave him a formal apology, admitting that the claims he first made in 1968, that was used as evidence of delusions in order to have him forcibly admitted, were in fact true... Nobody were willing to admit that the hospitalisation was politically motivated, but given the fact it's hard to conclude otherwise.
It shows how insidious claims like these could be: Everything he did to fight his hospitalisation and diagnosis was used as additional evidence of his supposed insanity.
I like to think that cases like this doesn't occur anymore..
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gustl_Mollath
I recall that in a TV discussion of the scandal a psychiatry professor was extremely critical of psychiatric profiles. I think she even said that she would not allow anyone to create one of herself.
Just look what they did to Forrestal in the early years of the takeover of the United States by the military-industrial complex:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/James_Forrestal#Psychiatric_tre...
https://firstlook.org/theintercept/2014/02/24/jtrig-manipula...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qiKMmrG1ZKU
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Political_psychology
(See also - http://psychiatricnews.wordpress.com/)
>If you're saying that psychology had severe abuse in the system early on then we both agree.
Nope. Still the same as it ever was.
Please could you point to a single "government appointed psychologist" saying [blah] about some figure? Because while I'm sure they're common in oppressive regimes I haven't heard of one recently in non-oppressive regimes.
> if an 'expert' (high priest) comes along with their statement that the individual has any one of the invented malladies in their bible (DSM-IV), then thats the end of that guy. Take him away!
There are abuses of the various rules for detaining and treating someone against their will. I mentioned that in my first reply. But it's not as easy as you suggest and hasn't been for some years now.
If you're saying that psychology had severe abuse in the system early on then we both agree.