Re:Why I'm Moving From Desktop Apps to Web Apps
by gruseom on Saturday September 05, 2009 @01:43PM
(#806808)
You make some good points. On this, though:
Andrew Chen recently blogged on this same topic
...I just read it. He gives tables of numbers and equations that as far as I can tell are completely made up. He also recommends practices that I think are pernicious, including:
Install itself on the system tray
Start up automatically when the OS loads
Run nicely in the background to pop up when appropriate
...and many other retention-happy features
("Happy" for whom? Certainly not the poor naive users I know whose computers are bogged down with programs that do these things.)
His post is intellectually dodgy in exactly the way that a lot of this kind of software is dodgy. Which makes me notice something I never thought of before: web apps feel cleaner. As a user, I control when I go to the website and use the product; there is less opportunity for semi-scrupulous vendors to mess with me.
Re:Why I'm Moving From Desktop Apps to Web Apps
by hernan7 on Sunday September 06, 2009 @02:44AM
(#807556)
Agreed 100%. Also, for enterprise/vertical app's that usually seem to be released half cooked, releasing them as web apps gives the developers fewer ways to foul up the user experience.
Andrew Chen recently blogged on this same topic
...I just read it. He gives tables of numbers and equations that as far as I can tell are completely made up. He also recommends practices that I think are pernicious, including:
("Happy" for whom? Certainly not the poor naive users I know whose computers are bogged down with programs that do these things.)His post is intellectually dodgy in exactly the way that a lot of this kind of software is dodgy. Which makes me notice something I never thought of before: web apps feel cleaner. As a user, I control when I go to the website and use the product; there is less opportunity for semi-scrupulous vendors to mess with me.