Re:The evidence that shows Iron Dome is not working
by thesimpsons1022 on Tuesday July 22, 2014 @02:06AM
(#8067580)
It is important to consider that Hamas doesn't have much "choice" in their missiles. They just use whatever they can get their hands on.
Re:The evidence that shows Iron Dome is not working
by ars on Tuesday July 22, 2014 @03:48AM
(#8067778)
> then it makes it makes sense that the IDF won't simply sit back and let Hamas fire away until they run out of rockets
As many other posters have shown, the analysis is incorrect.
And Israel did in fact wait a while and just let them shoot. They escalated to a ground phase because of terror tunnels - missiles are a lower priority. You can tell because of where Israel is targeting during the ground phase - they have not gone deep into Gaza, but are staying right near the border where the tunnels start.
I'm curious about Hamas' choice in rockets though. Would larger rockets present as easier targets for the Iron Dome? If so, then the Iron Dome does indeed serve an important purpose by limiting Hamas to rockets small enough to be harmless to shelters. If not, then why would Hamas not use rockets large enough to penetrate a shelter?
Finally, let's assume the ineffectiveness of the Iron Dome was commonly known. Given the sharp increase in IDF casualties after the ground invasion started, would it still have made sense to invade if there was no fear that Israelis might lose confidence in the Iron Dome?