News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by judk on Sunday July 20, 2014 @10:51PM (#8062297)
Like ancient dietary laws, our moral code may be rooted in ancient common wisdom about healthy choices.
Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by logicchains on Monday July 21, 2014 @12:12AM (#8062461)
Eh, ancient wisdom doesn't seem to have done a great job in terms of moral codes. Slavery, institutionalised racism and sexism, foot-binding, debtor's prisons, despotism, pedophilia; all examples of practices deriving from ancient wisdom that today are considered unacceptable.
Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by rdtsc on Monday July 21, 2014 @12:37AM (#8062503)
> all examples of practices deriving from ancient wisdom that today are considered unacceptable.

However only survivors after tens or hundreds of thousands of years are able to log in and comment on HN about it. Some of the abhorrent ancient "wisdoms" are well, ...abhorrent. Others maybe the reason we are still here (as opposed some other people being here, or, no human species at all).

Also, it is probably reasonable to assume the same "morals" the kept a group of hunter gatherers together are today responsible to racism and hate between groups.

To really even begin to look at cause you'd at least want a situation where two very similar groups differed only in one aspect you are trying to measure and then observe how both groups evolved.

Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by logicchains on Monday July 21, 2014 @01:01AM (#8062547)
>Also, it is probably reasonable to assume the same "morals" the kept a group of hunter gatherers together are today responsible to racism and hate between groups.

Good point. It's important to remember that evolution (including of the cultural variety) ultimately selects for survival. If group A is super happy and peaceful, and group B is unhappy and violent, if group B uses its capacity for violence to conquer group A then ultimately it will be group B's genetic/cultural traits that survive into the future.

Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by XorNot on Monday July 21, 2014 @01:52AM (#8062649)
Moreover it only selects for immediate term survival - it does not choose long-term optimum solutions (see: Peacock feathers, where creating impressive plumage is pretty much orthogonal to actual fitness) nor does it brook short term deficits for long term gains.

It is an abhorrent moral compass.

Re:Love People, Not Pleasure by marvy on Monday July 21, 2014 @12:29AM (#8062488)
Hey, you win some, you lose some. They still got a few things right.