News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by juretriglav on Sunday July 20, 2014 @03:52PM (#8061309)
See also:

http://peerlibrary.org http://www.pubpeer.com

There have been many more "comment on scientific papers" sites that came before these, including one I built myself in 2011. This is a really difficult market to succeed in, in fact, no one up to this point has. I hope you do. Good luck!

Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by jasonpriem on Sunday July 20, 2014 @09:21PM (#8062133)
And if you'd like a yet more comprehensive list of these "comment on scientific papers" sites, here's a community-curated list of 'em I started...there's around 50 listed now I think: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1HD-BEaVeDdFjjCNFkb0j3pvw...

It's a great idea and I hope someone finds the way to make it work.

Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by alixander on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:44PM (#8061623)
Ah I searched for similar sites before making this but missed these, thanks for sharing them! Pubpeer describes itself as for researchers/scientists but Peerlibrary seems to be pretty close.

A little difference in intent: The idea I had in mind wasn't for someone to particularly do research/collaborate in a field, but just to discover interesting/enlightening papers to read given the urge to learn, in-depth, something new. I thought about attaching a "pre-requisites" fields or "difficulty" field but I wasn't sure if that'd work. The inspiration was just some people posting in my school's Computer Science group that they wanted to start reading research papers, asking where to start. Hopefully in the near future the "Most Favorite" will be a good list to begin with.

Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by paletoy on Monday July 21, 2014 @08:12AM (#8063346)
Not wanting to discourage you, but reddit.com/r/science does something pretty similar and very successfully - they have 6 million subscribers ,many comm enters are scientists, and the comment quality is usually very high , and they have the reddit mail support which is highly conductive to getting responses from people.
Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by dalek2point3 on Sunday July 20, 2014 @04:17PM (#8061374)
care to elaborate more? I've always been interested in something like this to succeed. Its ridiculous that even today research papers have to go to an unknown set of referees who have no help from a wider bunch of more intelligent people to help them dissect whats good and bad about the paper. It is also great for outsiders/newcomers to quickly understand what the research community thinks about a particular paper.
Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by alphydan on Sunday July 20, 2014 @05:58PM (#8061668)
Or, an open access journal (with discussions and feedback) that I enjoy reading and will probably submit to in the future is https://peerj.com/

In physics there's obviously the ArXiv, and various sites to rate and comment like, https://scirate.com/

Re:Show HN: Coredemia – share and discuss research papers by Scitr on Sunday July 20, 2014 @08:44PM (#8062071)
Scitr.com is different.