News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re: Deeply embedded DSLs in Haskell: overloading everything ... by anonymousDan on Friday September 04, 2009 @05:15PM (#805738)
Interesting. What about OCaml? I assume they have some kind of macro support. Assuming it is not as simple to work with as Lisp, how does it compare to the "Haskell-style" macros of Template Haskell?
Re: Deeply embedded DSLs in Haskell: overloading everything ... by blasdel on Friday September 04, 2009 @05:51PM (#805817)
OCaml comes with (and is implemented using) camlp4 -- it's an extraordinarily powerful "Pre-Processor-Pretty-Printer" that operates directly on a concrete syntax for the language.

Classical Lisp macros are only 'cleaner' by cheating.

Most of Template Haskell is about solving a different problem (A statically-type-checked meta-language for generating code that must be statically type-checked) -- and thus is pretty messy. It's still way cleaner than any of its predecessors (at least of the ones I've used).

Re: Deeply embedded DSLs in Haskell: overloading everything ... by dons on Friday September 04, 2009 @06:05PM (#805841)
Yes, note also that Haskell itself is the Template Haskell metalanguage. I.e. Haskell programs use Haskell to modify their own AST at compile time, giving you arbitrary AST power.