Re:“Aliens Cause Global Warming,” a lecture by Michael Crichton
by pron on Saturday July 19, 2014 @09:01AM
(#8057374)
I don't know anything about global warming research to comment about the conclusion of the text, but I can say something about what is certainly a religious belief infecting those who respect science, and are then led to respect "science": nutrition. The truth is that we know very little about human nutrition, especially in healthy individuals. When John Ioannidis demonstrated that most published medical research is false (wholly or partially), he singled out nutrition and gene-association as two especially problematic fields. Yet, the reason many believe that reading some papers and changing their diets to include more or less protein -- or more or less fiber, or more or less fat -- has an effect on their health is pure religion and magical thinking. This magical thinking stems from a possibly innate (and certainly ingrained) belief that "our body is a temple", or that "we are what we eat", which is a particular manifestation of the more general psychological desire in what Jonathan Haidt calls "purity". This psychological need is combined with the false[1] seemingly-scientific belief that our bodies accumulate damage over time.
The scientific truth is that (other than obviously pathological cases of eating poison, or living on just fries for a year) we simply don't know what food is good for us, and certainly not in what quantity. It's actually worse: we don't even know if diet (again, non pathological) has any effect on health. It is absolutely possible (and even likely), that our bodies are certainly capable of retaining good and disposing of bad nutrients, as long as our diet is somewhere within a very large "normal" range.
But nutrition is another of these scientific religions of our times, which infects actual scientists, too, and affects their research (like various papers linking diet to disease through a correlation with cholesterol -- an unproven pathogen).
The scientific truth is that (other than obviously pathological cases of eating poison, or living on just fries for a year) we simply don't know what food is good for us, and certainly not in what quantity. It's actually worse: we don't even know if diet (again, non pathological) has any effect on health. It is absolutely possible (and even likely), that our bodies are certainly capable of retaining good and disposing of bad nutrients, as long as our diet is somewhere within a very large "normal" range.
But nutrition is another of these scientific religions of our times, which infects actual scientists, too, and affects their research (like various papers linking diet to disease through a correlation with cholesterol -- an unproven pathogen).
[1]: http://gravityandlevity.wordpress.com/2009/07/08/your-body-w...