DFEOJM says the site is up if it is physically contactable -- in this case the site is contactable, and it responds with "this site is down" (but as HTTP/200 because the page still has some content rather than being an server error)
That links says it's down!
(and it's down for me, here in Yorkshire)
http://www.downforeveryoneorjustme.com/www.bbc.co.uk