We often say, "X will fail because I don't do X, and this proposed change makes me like X even less."
But if you're already not doing X, the change isn't for you anyway.*
Charitably though, we might interpret that argument as "My concerns are shared to a lesser extent by the marginal user of X. This change amplifies these concerns. Therefore, the change will cause X to lose marginal users."
For me, I don't go to the movies anymore because the internet is amazing and screens are cheap. Also, I like older movies as much as new ones, and being in a room with friends more than being with strangers.
I assume, maybe incorrectly, that the reason most movie consumers don't feel like I do is because they are not rabid technophiles. Maybe they just don't realize the fountain of entertainment they can easily put on a spectacularly sized display in their own home.
If I'm right, that that's the barrier, then once late adopters realize this, it may be game over for cinemas.
Maybe I'm wrong. We should ask, "Why do people actually go to the movies?"
*EDIT: It's a bit like everyone's complaint that 24 hour news isn't more intelligent. There was a panel at the Aspen Ideas Festival where MSNBC’s Lawrence O’Donnell basically said: We'd love to tell complex and deep stories. People who enjoy such stories though have busy lives and aren't home during primetime, they're going to the ballet, or outdoors, or reading a novel, and getting their news by scanning the internet for a few minutes each day. We run the market experiment against PBS every night.
Now admittedly I work in film so I care more than the typical cinemagoer about these things. But there is a vast difference between watching a well-photographed film on even the largest home theater screen and watching it projected full size with appropriate anamorphic lenses and so forth.
1. Get more people to go out to the theater for movies.
2. Get people who do go, to go more often.
3. Get people who do go, to pay more.
Now it seems clear they hope that this tech movement will support (3) above, but I'm thinking they also want (1) and / or (2) as well. And that's where I think this will fall short. That's where people like me, who do go to the movies, albeit not terribly often, probably aren't going to suddenly start going to 2x or 3x (or more) more movies, just because the screen is bigger/brighter. And I suspect the same is true for non-movie-goers.
Conversely, there is a risk that if they roll out these new projectors, and do raise prices, that they'll find still more people choosing to stay home, if they decide the increase in screen quality doesn't justify the price.
Anyway, don't get me wrong... it's not that I think this is a Bad Idea or anything. I am just skeptical that it's going to be the magic ticket to a massive surge in profitability for movie theaters and movie production companies.