I feel like the biases come from the origin of programming. But to suggest that it is somehow exclusively mathematics because of its origin is puzzling. It is quite clearly mostly words, many of which are arranged into sentences based upon a strict grammar.
It's also odd in that the reason the original article was written was to suggest that it wasn't an insurmountable field, and that many more people could probably learn it if they were not intimated. It's odd that the response seems to be "FEEL INTIMIDATED MORTAL!". I feel like we're seeing gatekeepers feeling threatened rather than a particularly logical argument.
mmmm. Lots of people would disagree with this :-)
> Until computers came along, math was entirely a theoretical pursuit
Not at all; mathematics always had applications. Not all mathematics, but it's certainly not that case that math was "all theory" and without serious application before computing.
> because for the first time we can take a mathematical idea from inside our heads and express it in a physical computer which executes it according to the logic we've defined.
We've had calculation assistants in various forms for centuries. Also, ballistics and construction based on mathematics are more-or-less "taking a mathematical idea and expressing it in the physical world".
There was plenty of mathematics before mathematics got to the point where we needed dedicated humans who spend their whole day computing things in a prescribed manner.
But regardless, for some reason I think the original post was referring to electrical/mechanical computers :)
"There was plenty of mathematics before mathematics got to the point where we needed dedicated humans who spend their whole day computing things in a prescribed manner."
More to the point, there was plenty of useful application of mathematics before then. Which I certainly agree with. My point was that most (and possibly all?) early application of mathematics required computation.
My comment, though, was mostly agreeing with you - just picking apart a technicality to get at some tangential interesting questions.
I think I have only one, which is the establishment of axioms, both philosophically (as a method) and specifically (e.g. in Elements).
A revisionist history might say that choosing axioms doesn't require any computation, just a keen sense of style and close observation of the world.
But actually, I'm sure that the choice of axioms was a long and drawn-out process informed mostly by computation and checks that the computed values/proven theorems matched with physical intuition. After all, that's kind-of how it's done today, even by people who have lots of experience with formal systems.
Now I really want to read pre-Euclidean mathematical philosophy to see if I'm correct :-)
Until computers came along, math was entirely a theoretical pursuit. The universe may be described by math, but it's impossible to know whether it is actually defined by math or if we just fit the math to the universe. But programming is different, because for the first time we can take a mathematical idea from inside our heads and express it in a physical computer which executes it according to the logic we've defined.
When you look at it this way you realize that it's exceedingly silly to try to separate programming that requires math knowledge from programming that doesn't. I mean no, programming usually does not require the infinitesimal slice of mathematics known as 9th grade algebra, but it does require logical thinking which is the basis of all mathematics.