Re:Why AI is a dangerous dream - interview with Noel Sharkey
by jacquesm on Friday September 04, 2009 @01:08PM
(#805223)
> relatively cheap
And who said HN has a shortage of humor :)
We know that intelligence can beget other intelligence, just like we know that life can beget life. But so far nobody to my knowledge has succeeded in creating artificial life without starting from something else that was already alive.
Intelligence might pose similar challenges.
> to understand AI we must first understand ourselves,
And therein lies the rub. We may get the mechanics down to every last nut and bolt and we may still not understand how intelligence arises. Just like we can not bring a recently deceased human back to life again. We have all the pieces but we do not know how to put the spark back in.
Compare it with a computer analogy, broken for sure, like all analogies, but it may bring the point across:
If an intelligence is a product of both software and hardware, and we seem to transfer the software through our genes and use that to build hardware that comes 'pre-programmed' then that program might not just run on any hardware. It may make lots of assumptions that we can not easily simulate without starting with a live brain and that would be cheating.
If we can not reliably bring people out of a coma, all the pieces are still there and appear to be 'plugged in' then how can we expect to generate an AI for which we do not even have the pieces ?
If I have a computer running an os in ram that I keyed in one fine sunday morning using the bootstrap panel, and which I then destroyed, next switch the machine off while it is working great you would have to know how I got the initial program in there before you could attempt to duplicate it.
Call it the case of the missing scaffolding, the last coupld of billion of years of evolution put that program where it sits, and from what we can see living creatures can pass it to the next generation in one form or another.
But it seems to be terribly difficult to switch the machine back on once it is of.
To me strong AI and life are quite strongly intertwined, I doubt you can have AI without artificial life, and that in and of itself may be quite enough of a challenge.
And who said HN has a shortage of humor :)
We know that intelligence can beget other intelligence, just like we know that life can beget life. But so far nobody to my knowledge has succeeded in creating artificial life without starting from something else that was already alive.
Intelligence might pose similar challenges.
> to understand AI we must first understand ourselves,
And therein lies the rub. We may get the mechanics down to every last nut and bolt and we may still not understand how intelligence arises. Just like we can not bring a recently deceased human back to life again. We have all the pieces but we do not know how to put the spark back in.
Compare it with a computer analogy, broken for sure, like all analogies, but it may bring the point across:
If an intelligence is a product of both software and hardware, and we seem to transfer the software through our genes and use that to build hardware that comes 'pre-programmed' then that program might not just run on any hardware. It may make lots of assumptions that we can not easily simulate without starting with a live brain and that would be cheating.
If we can not reliably bring people out of a coma, all the pieces are still there and appear to be 'plugged in' then how can we expect to generate an AI for which we do not even have the pieces ?
If I have a computer running an os in ram that I keyed in one fine sunday morning using the bootstrap panel, and which I then destroyed, next switch the machine off while it is working great you would have to know how I got the initial program in there before you could attempt to duplicate it.
Call it the case of the missing scaffolding, the last coupld of billion of years of evolution put that program where it sits, and from what we can see living creatures can pass it to the next generation in one form or another.
But it seems to be terribly difficult to switch the machine back on once it is of.
To me strong AI and life are quite strongly intertwined, I doubt you can have AI without artificial life, and that in and of itself may be quite enough of a challenge.