News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The History of Civilization by ekianjo on Thursday July 17, 2014 @09:27PM (#8051221)
> Meier consciously skated away from the fact that colonials enslaved and exterminated other human beings in order to sell a game,

I don't agree. Colonization as a game clearly shows there were different methods to colonize the new Land based on the nations' strategies. The French, for example, were rarely known to exterminate locals, on the contrary usually forged alliances and friendship with local populations. That's what you see as well in "The Last Mohican": french colons being very close to Indians, and there are many sources to confirm that point. So Colonization was not all done the Spanish way, and most of the deaths the locals endured came from viral infections spreading in non-immunized populations and certainly not slavery or battle. There were reports from Spaniards entering cities in south-America, expecting resistance but instead finding most of the people dying from infections.

Re:The History of Civilization by eropple on Thursday July 17, 2014 @09:51PM (#8051273)
The French certainly did, you're right, and Colonization even namedrops the coureurs de bois. But (as far as I can tell) there is not a single use of the word "Africa" in the game. The only mention of "slavery" that I can find in the game--which I have installed, because aside from its super problematic presentation of history it's a really great game--is in the little Colonopedia blurb about Bartolome de las Casas...where they then elide that he advocated enslaving Africans instead. (And, certainly, he later recanted that position. So say that too! But paint the whole picture.)

So, sure, you're right, #NotAllColonizers--but seriously, do you think that the ability to play in that way obviates the duty to actually present history as it, like, was, and not as will make your purchasers feel comfy?

Art is hard. Come correct or don't come at all.

Re:The History of Civilization by ekianjo on Thursday July 17, 2014 @10:02PM (#8051300)
> But there is not a single use of the word "Africa" in the game.

OK, I'll grant you that, but at the same time, massive slavery scale occurred mainly after 1600-1700 (see Wikipedia reference below) so while slave trade started earlier it was not prominent in the early colony days, and it was first led by Portuguese and Spanish before other nations opted in.

> It is estimated that more than half of the entire slave trade took place during the 18th century, with the British, Portuguese and French being the main carriers of nine out of ten slaves abducted from Africa.[44]

Certainly the game is not perfect on that aspect, but since it's an American game, it would probably be very sensitive to touch upon that subject in the first place. I can't even imagine how that would be sold there if slavery had been integrated.

Re:The History of Civilization by eropple on Thursday July 17, 2014 @10:59PM (#8051465)
> OK, I'll grant you that, but at the same time, massive slavery scale occurred mainly after 1600-1700 (see Wikipedia reference below) so while slave trade started earlier it was not prominent in the early colony days, and it was first led by Portuguese and Spanish before other nations opted in.

The game ends in 1850 if you haven't completed the Revolutionary War before then. And Simon Bolivar is available as a "founding father". He was born in 1783. The 18th century is very much in play.

> Certainly the game is not perfect on that aspect, but since it's an American game, it would probably be very sensitive to touch upon that subject in the first place. I can't even imagine how that would be sold there if slavery had been integrated.

You are really underselling it. It's not "not perfect", it's bad. And I am an American, saying this. If honesty won't sell, fine. Don't make it. That's a better alternative than to whitewash history.

Re:The History of Civilization by slgeorge on Friday July 18, 2014 @08:54AM (#8052725)
Uh actually if you're going to define it as 'Art' then it's entitled to take a "view point" which you may not thinks is correct, but which is intended to cause a reaction. Which you are having. There is no duty to be truthful - which is why it's "Art" and not a history book.

And, what do you mean by "correct" anyway. You mean the current view of what you deem to be correct - which may not be others viewpoint, and which probably was not the viewpoint of people in future or the past. And, anyway the only viewpoint that matter is that of the creator of the work.

So no sorry, I think you mean "if I did something about Colonization I would do it differently and the current work does not properly represent my viewpoint".

Not as pithy though.

Re:The History of Civilization by eropple on Friday July 18, 2014 @10:47AM (#8053280)
You are asserting that doing your level best to ignore the worst offenses of American history is somehow valid.

This isn't merely disagreement on something that's opinion-based. This is ignoring factual things that happened. White guys rewriting history to make then look good is objectively bad. This is simply not that complex.