I get the feeling that you're trying to play the messages off as not being automated as they come from Erik, but people already know they're automated. The gig is up. You could simply create an account such as "ProductHuntNotifier" or equivalent and remove any ambiguity.
I still think that the messages are both relevant and important.
You're in a unique position where you can even manually add and promote new startups to Product Hunt yourselves followed by automating a tweet out to the founder(s) and growth hack user acquisition that way. This seems to be the approach you're taking. I do applaud the fact you go so far as to do the legwork of finding the twitter accounts associated with the startup; that task is by no means automated. Most people can't take this approach as they have nothing beneficial to offer the user they're tweeting to.
Because there's some value add to what they're doing, I'm not sure I'd say it's a cut and dry case of calling it spam given it's not fully automated and the startups in question are getting promoted. It seems mutually beneficial in many ways.
If we can't find the founder's Twitter handle, we send a message to the startup/product's Twitter account.
Remember the InstallMonetizer incident while back: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5092711
I actually think it's something they teach them to do.
Many of them respond with a "Thanks". Not one person has said "Spam".
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8032837
I hope you're not going to continue to do that. I get you're hustling, but this isn't the right way to do this.
> Not one person has said "Spam".
I marked the tweet as spam via the report the tweet feature, I don't know if people usually actually reply as "this is spam."
I agree with the other comments that this is a useful feature, but would be more well suited for a customized twitter account with a name explaining it better.
If anyone has suggestions for ways to automate part of this, as it takes a long time, i'm open!
Perhaps you could require your product submitters to insert the contact email for the products they are submitting. Then, you could auto email the founder as soon as their product is posted on Product Hunt.
for some reason, we find that people are more responsive on twitter.
Also, we're not using an automated script to send these tweets.
Clearly, you guys are also trying to benefit from the increased publicity from using a public message "board" platform instead of a more private form of communication. I believe that may be the origin of some of these concerns. You guys aren't addressing the fact that you are doing this on a public platform to promote your site. Instead, you are still trying to argue that you are doing this completely independent of the traffic benefits....
Most people's twitter settings require that they follow you to DM them.
"e-mail them with a bot that scrapes emails off the product site"
Not a bad idea and we could make some educated guesses as to what the email address is (e.g. [email protected]). That said, we've found some founders aren't as quick to respond to email as they are on Twitter. I personally prefer the more ephemeral nature of Twitter for these type of notifications as my email inbox is already difficult enough to manage.
"Clearly, you guys are also trying to benefit from the increased publicity from using a public message 'board' platform"
We send direct @mentions to founders/startups on Twitter. These tweets will not surface in other's Twitter feed unless they're following both people.
http://www.producthunt.com/posts/instant-chemistry
http://www.producthunt.com/posts/jumpido
http://www.producthunt.com/posts/customeed
Maybe if they made it something you could subscribe to, opt-in, I would think it wasn't spam, but as it stands now, getting a notification on all of my Twitter enabled devices about something I don't care about, that I didn't ask for nor subscribe to, is spam. That some are advocating actually "scraping emails" to automate email notifications because this is so useful just leaves me a little bit dumbfounded.
It seems to me that companies might even actually pay for a service like this and if enough people thought it added value, I don't see where the issue with scraping emails is. Perhaps you could enlighten me or provide a different viewpoint as this would be something that I'd have no issue implementing myself and the fact that it scares you so much has me worried that I would be overreaching if I ever did. I just don't see why an email scraper is seen as inherently evil?
[0] I imagine a system where there has to be a minimum amount of comments and not one in which the only comment is made by Erik (or a bot) and used as the "motivation" for responding to the thread as a founder.
I find it totally bizarre that you would claim "you don't care about" this. As in, I do care about it.
Am I saying it's okay for someone to start talking about my product, then spam me to let me know this is happening?
Yes.
https://twitter.com/ErikTorenberg/media
He has posted hundreds of reply spam promoting Product Hunt on Twitter. He must be running some kind of script because he has posted so many replies many with product specific screenshots, I can’t imagine someone doing this manually so quickly (every few minutes).
I understand “growth hacking” and sometimes promoting yourself can seem like spam to some, but this really is just spam, and it’s not the good kind. This is probably in violation of Twitter's TOS and not what people should have to be exposed to, especially if you're trying to build a brand. This makes me just want to never use the product, and I really like supporting YC companies and prefer to give the benefit of the doubt and assume good faith in the face of self-promotion. But this is just a little bit too much.