News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The New Airbnb by adamesque on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @03:31PM (#8044009)
I'm not sure I've ever met an opinion on a logo, name, or anything creative less than a month old that was worth a damn.

When faced with something new, the tendency is to focus on the superficial, the easy joke, and it's too easy to let other opinions steer your own; they're momentarily on equal footing, you see. But the work will last longer than this moment. Your own opinion will evolve. The crowd will move on to the next easy joke and hip-shot reaction.

That's why I like to avoid making more than cautious, small statements until I've had a while to reflect. This work looks nice to me. There's potential for great marketing in an individually customizable — but still distinctive (or distinguishable) — logomark.

Most of this commentary feels like the person in the code review who hasn't taken the time to digest the intent of the code, so they comment on formatting. Whitespace. Trees. Not the forest.

Re:The New Airbnb by _delirium on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @08:03PM (#8045303)
I clicked on this thread wondering: 1) why is this news?; and 2) why are there so many comments? I'm not sure I learned the answer to either one...
Re:The New Airbnb by personjerry on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @08:42PM (#8045417)
I believe this comment was formatted incorrectly. I think this is how it should've been posted:

>> I'm not sure I've ever met an opinion on a logo, name, or anything creative less than a month old that was worth a damn.

>> When faced with something new, the tendency is to focus on the superficial, the easy joke, and it's too easy to let other opinions steer your own; they're momentarily on equal footing, you see. But the work will last longer than this moment. Your own opinion will evolve. The crowd will move on to the next easy joke and hip-shot reaction.

>> That's why I like to avoid making more than cautious, small statements until I've had a while to reflect. This work looks nice to me. There's potential for great marketing in an individually customizable — but still distinctive (or distinguishable) — logomark.

> Most of this commentary feels like the person in the code review who hasn't taken the time to digest the intent of the code, so they comment on formatting. Whitespace. Trees. Not the forest.

Re:The New Airbnb by OrwellianChild on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @06:12PM (#8044909)
This is on-point for most logo designs, if not all. You can only really see the bad ones in retrospect (the London 2012 Olympics logo comes to mind [1]).

That said, I think the motion-picture used as the background to the call to action is going to be very short-lived on basic UI principles. It's distracting, low-contrast, and pulls people away from the text, button, etc. I'm sure A/B testing will resolve the issue pretty quickly, but it's very trendy right now - Paypal is doing it too. [2]

[1] http://www.adweek.com/adfreak/london-2012-olympic-logo-was-i... [2] https://www.paypal.com/

Re:The New Airbnb by prawn on Thursday July 17, 2014 @02:52AM (#8046356)
The background movies that I saw while watching for a while just weren't appealing. AirBnb is full of beautiful, crazy and exciting accommodation options and now instead of showcasing those, they're pushing fairly bland movies and generic location shots first. Any travel website can do that.
Re:The New Airbnb by mschaecher on Thursday July 17, 2014 @05:33AM (#8046623)
As a former Airbnb employee, this is honestly the only thing I don't like about the rebrandredesign!

Airbnb pry has one of, if not THE, world's largest collection of amazing real estate photography.

It's possible some massive real estate company might have as much, but I can't imagine how Airbnb doesn't have the largest collection of lived-in home interiors by a long shot.

Re:The New Airbnb by bellerocky on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @06:06PM (#8044884)
You are correct because first impressions don't matter.
Re:The New Airbnb by personjerry on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @08:40PM (#8045409)
I can't tell if this is sarcasm, but if it is, well keep in mind that biting sarcasm isn't really constructive discussion.

If it's not, I apologize for misunderstanding. You may want to explain your thoughts a little more next time.