Protecting your privacy is worth it, and despite what you think, there are strategies that are likely to help protect quite a bit of it, if the impetus becomes strong enough.
That's just not going to happen. Large entities are run by people who are inherently trustworthy. This is why there's a need for privacy. I don't want to be judged on my heart rate, physical ailments, preferred music, or any of the million other items you'd like to be public. I don't think you have any idea what harm revealing such information might cause. Say I'm gay and living in some backwards town in the south. Would I want my neighbors to find out so they can tie me up to a pickup truck and drag me to death? This is just one of infinite possibilities for harm resulting in all data being accessible. Your proposal is absolutely ludicrous.
A person who fears for life due to their personal identity probably would be a bit adept at vetting potentially dangerous areas.
For that matter, whatever gave you the idea that most people get to choose what neighborhood they're going to live in? Poor people pretty often live wherever fate deposited them. The whole idea reminds of a joke Bill Maher made during the Hurricane Katrina aftermath, the gist of which was George Bush saying something to Cheney like, "I don't understand what all those people are still doing in the Superdome. Why don't they get in their SUVs and drive to their summer homes?"
Setting aside how comfortable I feel with the rest of your suggestion (I don't), this seems to miss a fundamental point: part of the reason that some information needs to be private is that it is how you authenticate yourself. In a world where you can easily get your welfare check, and where everyone else knows all relevant information about you, how do you stop someone else from getting your welfare check? (For the near future, anyway, presumably a physical presence will trump any information-based authentication; but having to be physically present for these transactions seems like it would erase the very convenience that is your goal.)
Regardless, I really don't know how you actually identify someone. Likely, as you say, physically being present(retina scan, fingerprinting, both?). You raise an interesting philosophical question; that is, what is identity?
It's not really a philosophical question being raised. The question of identity is always, "Is the person trying to authenticate the same person as someone with whom I have some relationship?" Online, you set up a username and password, and the presumption is that any person with that username and password is the same person who set up the account. If you want to prove your "real" identity, you're basically doing the same thing, but you're instead trying to prove that you're the same person as the one who was awarded your driver's license, or the same person whose birth is certified by your birth certificate.
Replacing the card requires physical presence, of course.
Which is why at least in BT senior developers on some systems had TS clearance.
Maybe if there were a surcharge for every unhealthful thing, people would choose to be healthier and healthcare costs would actually come down.
yeah,and why not a mandatory rfid chip so they can monitor your health in realtime and adjust your premium,hey?. And you are driving ? you're then more likely to have an accident so your insurance should go up.Watching TV on the sofa instead of running? not healthy! Here you pay 10% more. Running? it's not unlikely you get a heart attack, what about 5% more?
Do you have any idea how stupid you sound?
And in broad strokes the concept is sound - Why should I pay for others' bad habits? I'm much more sympathetic to things you can't control (and admittedly there is a gray zone in between).
The example that really bugs me is federally backed flood insurance. People build homes in places that aren't safe, and then taxpayers bail them out. Moral hazard.
Hah. So, I live in the Netherlands. Do you think that everybody who lives here should move to Belgium or Germany then, given the flooding hazard here? Are the Delta Works projects a huge waste of tax payer's money? Or is it different when your entire country is at flood risk?
We as a society need to first trust a large entity(which obviously right now is not gonna happen) with as much personally identifying information as possible in the hopes of creating an authority and allowing us to navigate the "system" much more easily(like I said renewing a Driver's License, getting a welfare check more quickly, processing a zoning request more easily, getting a medical history, etc.).
After that happens, we should hopefully then feel okay about sharing that personal information publicly. Not a selective news feed like FB but the equivalent of a publicly available intelligence dossier on yourself that anyone(including yourself) has free access to. I know it seems crazy, but I really believe that's where it's headed anyway.
No more background checks or credit score checks or walled gardens etc. My current location, my current heart rate, my arrest record, all my google searches(eesh) my last mammogram or testicular cancer exam, etc. is on display for all(including myself) to check and find out instantly and for free. The world would collapse. Economies might actually collapse though.
Obviously, society is not ready for that sort of thing just yet, but that should have been the direction Google should have gone with Google+(or Google Identity or whatever they want to call it) eventually.
You can't index the world's information if most of it is "private".