News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Patent trolls now account for 67 percent of all new paten... by SilasX on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:56PM (#8038615)
IMHO, that doesn't address the real problem, of patents that shouldn't have been granted (because anyone faced with the same problem does the same thing without being helped by the patent description).

In fact, it makes that problem worse, because the assessed or hypothetical market value of the obvious, or "too old" invention is much higher. For example, what happens if someone is (by foolishness) granted a patent on fire or the wheel? They'd pay a higher tax, but be entitled to a much bigger "extortion" from the economy. So it would "turbocharge" the incentive to slip undeserved patents through.

IMHO, the real problem goes away when patents only go to legitimate "oh my word I wouldn't have thought of that in a thousand years" innovations, at which point it would be much harder to say, "why should anyone have to pay to use that?"

Re:Patent trolls now account for 67 percent of all new paten... by kansface on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @06:16PM (#8039441)
Sure, but legislation that throws out 99% of existing patents will never fly because legitimate businesses who have spent billions of dollars on them. The only possible political solution is to filter out trolls.
Re:Patent trolls now account for 67 percent of all new paten... by narag on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @07:55AM (#8041573)
Would it be technically possible in the USA to create a special jurisdiction for patents?

That could prevent a number of the current problems: certain states particularly kind with patent suits, some judges ignoring higher courts resolution...

Re:Patent trolls now account for 67 percent of all new paten... by chc on Wednesday July 16, 2014 @10:31AM (#8042174)
A special court for patents already exists in many places. In the US, it's the Federal Circuit Court of Appeals.
Re:Patent trolls now account for 67 percent of all new paten... by narag on Thursday July 17, 2014 @02:25AM (#8046294)
Appeals, that't not what I mean, but a system where patent demands need to be started out of ordinary courts.