Re:The Case for Why Marketing Should Have Its Own Engineers
by TheOtherHobbes on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:46PM
(#8038234)
I'm not sold.
The first thing you see on Knewton's page is 'Every education leader needs an adaptive learning infrastructure'.
Then you have a buzzword car crash with 'Adaptive Ontology', 'Model Computation Engine', etc.
It's a good bet that most people - education leaders included - know nothing about ML. So what they see here is a page of jargon they don't understand, and some social proof (not so bad, but a bit late.)
You don't get a plain English benefit statement - 'See how Knewton improves student achievement' - until you scroll to the bottom of the page and/or start clicking through to the next pages.
Is this design really the result of user analytics?
Did the page say something like 'We help your students learn", but that was taken down because it didn't get conversions?
Bottom line - I'd be surprised if the content on this page makes it easier to sell the product to first-time visitors. (And it looks like an interesting product. But I can guess what the words mean, so I'm probably not a typical customer.)
I'm open to the idea that marketing needs engineering, and vice versa. But I'd suggest that more than anything, start-ups need a good customer champion who can step outside the company culture to provide evidence-based reviews of marketing materials and products as customers see them - not as marketing or engineering want them to be seen.
Analytics may not be enough, because you can't be sure you're asking the right questions and mis-optimizing for a small local maximum while missing something important elsewhere.
The first thing you see on Knewton's page is 'Every education leader needs an adaptive learning infrastructure'.
Then you have a buzzword car crash with 'Adaptive Ontology', 'Model Computation Engine', etc.
It's a good bet that most people - education leaders included - know nothing about ML. So what they see here is a page of jargon they don't understand, and some social proof (not so bad, but a bit late.)
You don't get a plain English benefit statement - 'See how Knewton improves student achievement' - until you scroll to the bottom of the page and/or start clicking through to the next pages.
Is this design really the result of user analytics?
Did the page say something like 'We help your students learn", but that was taken down because it didn't get conversions?
Bottom line - I'd be surprised if the content on this page makes it easier to sell the product to first-time visitors. (And it looks like an interesting product. But I can guess what the words mean, so I'm probably not a typical customer.)
I'm open to the idea that marketing needs engineering, and vice versa. But I'd suggest that more than anything, start-ups need a good customer champion who can step outside the company culture to provide evidence-based reviews of marketing materials and products as customers see them - not as marketing or engineering want them to be seen.
Analytics may not be enough, because you can't be sure you're asking the right questions and mis-optimizing for a small local maximum while missing something important elsewhere.