Re:Ask HN: Why not Flex?
by lhorie on Thursday September 03, 2009 @06:40PM
(#803745)
I really don't buy the user-hostile argument. You write your code and you get a SWF. Youtube has SWFs. Newgrounds has SWFs. DeviantArt has SWFs.
Normally the thought of whether something is running in a sandbox is not a concern if I'm using any of these sites. The only times I would get annoyed by load speed issues had nothing to do with the SWF format, it would usually be of the magnitude of the whole site being overloaded.
I could say Meebo doesn't feel native to the browser either, but I think we're way too much into the opinion territory to be saying that, generically speaking, x or y technology is hostile to all users (especially without knowing what the app is to begin with).
Normally the thought of whether something is running in a sandbox is not a concern if I'm using any of these sites. The only times I would get annoyed by load speed issues had nothing to do with the SWF format, it would usually be of the magnitude of the whole site being overloaded.
I could say Meebo doesn't feel native to the browser either, but I think we're way too much into the opinion territory to be saying that, generically speaking, x or y technology is hostile to all users (especially without knowing what the app is to begin with).