News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:01AM (#8034704)
Could we please stop hating on Scribd? In addition to being rude, it's also mistaken: I've found PDFs on Scribd that simply aren't available anywhere else, because the original links on other sites became broken. This is somewhat common for academic papers, for example. Yes, I had to upload a PDF in order to download the PDF from Scribd, but that's a fair trade; I chose to upload an academic paper that perhaps might be useful to someone else.
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by Camillo on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:07AM (#8034724)
When you have a horrible, user-hostile service, being the only place to find something only tends to make people hate you more.
Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @12:29AM (#8034776)
Which is better: not being able to find something at all, or having to jump through a hoop to download it?

I thought HN was objective. Maybe that's changing.

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by girvo on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:07AM (#8035031)
> I thought HN was objective. Maybe that's changing.

No, I don't think so, I just think a lot of people here disagree with you in your judgement of Scribd.

Hopefully this service can have the utility of Scribd as you've described and keep it's lovely usability.

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by sillysaurus3 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:24AM (#8035071)
The lack of response to my point that Scribd has content not found anywhere else is the most telling. Objectively, it seems like that point should win the debate. The disagreement is therefore subjective.

I wouldn't quite call this "tribalism," but perhaps it's one step short. In the old days of HN, a valid point wouldn't simply be dismissed without a response. The fact that no one is stepping up to point out why I'm mistaken is suggestive; if it continues to happen, then it's indicative of a trend. And over the last year I've seen this happen to others somewhat frequently.

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by icebraining on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @08:15AM (#8035938)
The disagreement is therefore subjective.

No, your reasoning is specious, you're assuming "Scribd has content nobody else has, therefore if there was no Scribd, there would be no content". This is simply broken logic.

Scribd is like the cup I used to drink water from this morning; if that particular cup hadn't been made, would I die of thirst?

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by joepie91_ on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @02:27AM (#8035076)
(There's a maximum nesting limit for replies?)

Scribd having a lot of unique content isn't a feature; it's an observed state. There is no reason why Scribd would exclusively be able to offer that, and any other PDF host wouldn't. It's simply a consequence of a lot of people using a service.

Scribd having amassed so much data due to their sheer size is not a point in favour of Scribd; if anything, it makes the walled-garden approach of Scribd even more frustrating.

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by sillysaurus5 on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:01AM (#8035164)
Are you sure? If an academic paper were to become lost from the internet because Internet Archive hadn't archived it and no other site mirrored it, then the world wouldn't be worse off as a result? That seems dubious.

And if it's true that the world is better off for Scribd having the paper, then it must be true that Scribd is beneficial to the world. The fact that people don't like it is irrelevant.

(I created a new account not to dodge downvotes, but because HN wouldn't let me continue submitting replies to this thread with my other one.)

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by icebraining on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @08:12AM (#8035927)
But the alternative to "Scribd having the paper" is not necessarily "no other site having it". If someone uploaded it to Scribd, why wouldn't they upload it to some other site instead?

Your argument is equivalent to saying: the registrar of google.com is MarkMonitor, therefore if MarkMonitor didn't exist, we wouldn't have Google.

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by girvo on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:50AM (#8035271)
> The fact that people don't like it is irrelevant.

It's really not, though. Scribd is terrible in terms of its user experience, and frankly it's interface is horrid in my opinion, but it has content that isn't found anywhere else (which is a plus). Those two are not mutually exclusive, you're drawing a false dichotomy. *shrugs

Re:PDFy – Instant PDF Host by seszett on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @03:27AM (#8035211)
> There's a maximum nesting limit for replies?

Usually when the "reply" link isn't shown, you can click on the comment's "link" link and reply from there.