Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by klochner on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:44PM
(#8032493)
Subjects received monetary payments for each good estimate.
Possible rewards were 4, 2, or 1 points if their estimates fell into the
10%, 20%, or 40% intervals around the truth; otherwise, they
received no points. The rewards applied to all rounds to make sure
that individuals took all of their decisions seriously. The correct
answer and the rewards for all
five estimates were only disclosed to
the subjects after the
fifth estimate. This reward structure in-
troduced incentives only to
find the truth and avoided incentives to
conform with others. Furthermore, there were no incentives for
strategic considerations. For example, there was no benefit of being better than others or of misleading others, because this did not
affect individuals
’
payments. There was also no possibility to help
others by deviating from the strategy to
find the best estimate.
Therefore, our experimental design put subjects into a situation in
which they would try to get as close to the truth as possible by using
their own knowledge and the estimates of others.
http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/05/10/1008636108.full...
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by SilasX on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:46PM
(#8032506)
Thanks for the correction -- for some reason, this isn't mentioned in the story, which is a pretty big omission.
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by apalmer on Monday July 14, 2014 @05:17PM
(#8033304)
basically this is saying the entire story is pretty much bunk. Its more than a significant omission, it invalidates the entire analysis presented.
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by eevilspock on Tuesday July 15, 2014 @01:10AM
(#8034903)
Seems to me you're proving the point of the article. Rather than contributing independent critical thinking, you're more motivated to pile onto the comments of others, to the point of not even bothering to understand the comment you're piling onto.
EDIT: per klochner's correction, the following is wrong, and they did get a monetary incentive, though it's not mentioned in the linked article (only the paper), which is a pretty significant difference!
Note that they did not provide a material incentive for accurate guesses, so I'm honestly surprised that this kind of confidence correlates with correctness. It requires that this feeling of confidence is more likely to happen in people who really do know better compared to those two don't know better. (Per the writeup, if you weight each guess in the average by confidence per this metric, then you get even more accurate answers than the simple mean).