Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by jhanschoo on Monday July 14, 2014 @01:46PM
(#8032163)
I wish the headline made it clear that the 'confidence' it refers to is not the personality trait associated with risk-taking and leadership but the more specific 'confidence' and stubbornness in one's own opinion that one has on a topic when one believes that their opinion is founded on valid information related to that topic that few others are aware of while they were forming their opinions.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by soneca on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:03PM
(#8032258)
You took 3 lines to explain the difference between the two meanings. How do you expect the writer to make it clear on a headline?
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by SilasX on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:32PM
(#8032728)
FWIW, I did it in one line [1]. But even better, I think the term "stubborn believers" is a better term and would have decreased the confusion, but note that it requires stubbornness plus disincentive for being wrong to correlate with correctness.
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by apalmer on Monday July 14, 2014 @05:19PM
(#8033318)
he just should not have used the word confidence in the headline.
He used to word confidence to make a more interesting headline, instead of using another word to make a more informative headline.
Re:Neurobiologists Reveal The Wisdom Of The Confident
by dkarl on Monday July 14, 2014 @09:11PM
(#8034183)
I would add that they are stubborn in their estimate of an objectively known quantity knowing that their estimate will be compared to the "correct" value. In a situation where that threat/reassurance is absent, the incentives could be entirely different.
(Using the length of a border defined by natural features [http://www.economist.com/node/13496212] as an objectively knowable value might be problematic, but I believe that was the intent.)