News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by ghshephard on Sunday July 13, 2014 @09:57PM (#8029247)
The theory (a 1/2 impact doesn't make any real difference when you are dealing with 1/10th drops based on distance) - doesn't match up with reality.

As one who has run a 1-Watt 900 Mhz Wireless Mesh omnidirectional network over distances of about 8km, I can tell you that the splitter that drops your power in half on the transmission/receive side, has a huge impact on networks that are close to the edge of your receive sensitivity. Enough so that we took some equipment that incorporated such a split in the signal strength, and sent it back to engineering for a 9 month spin to remove such a splitter. 1/2 drop = 3dB loss.

If you have a receive sensitivity of about -102 dBm, and your signal is just on the edge at -100 dBm, and you inject a splitter (a 3dB loss) - you lose a good chunk of your transmitters. It's the difference between being able to run a 4km hop and an 8km hop.

Here is my favorite tutorial on "how far" - it walks the right line between theory and practice.

http://www.afar.net/tutorials/how-far/

Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by Retric on Sunday July 13, 2014 @11:17PM (#8029402)
Power drops as R^2, coverage area is R^2 so cutting output by N reduces your coverage area by N.
Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by colanderman on Monday July 14, 2014 @12:39AM (#8029527)
To reiterate (because although I had the same thought as you it took me a moment to realize what you meant), OP is measuring the wrong thing for multi-user scenarios. Losing 10 ft from 1000 ft radius due to a 20% power loss might sound inconsequential (only 1%, right?), until you realize that's ~31,000 ft². That's ¾ acre, or 20% of your users. Nothing to sneeze at.
Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by ghshephard on Monday July 14, 2014 @02:35AM (#8029727)
In my scenario, I'm saying the addition of a diplexor (in this case, a single antenna port to serve both 900 MHz, and 2.5Ghz, so the signal was split to two RF chips - about 3 dB of loss) - the typical distance at 0.1% BER, with the exact same antenna gain, Free Space Loss, LMR400 loss, etc.. dropped from 8 km radius in all directions down to a little over 4 km radius.
Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by mungoman2 on Monday July 14, 2014 @03:37AM (#8029901)
How do you get 20%? The area difference between a circle with a radius of 1000 vs 990 is 2%.
Re:Wifi and the square of the radius by colanderman on Monday July 14, 2014 @08:18AM (#8030520)
Oh shit, you're right. I used 900 instead of 990. That's what I get for doing math at midnight. Too late to edit it now.