Here is another thing, tell me if this is true of you: I can't understand anything about how to solve a problem if I don't know completely 'understand' the context. In other words, I took several years of experimental physics at University, but it was totally bewildering to me. I understood the experiments perfectly (I mean, they aren't anything complex at that level), I understood the apparatus, I understood the mathematics and so on and on. At some point in every experiment, however, you had to decide whether your data supported or did not support the hypothesis. This is usually pretty obvious, but you were supposed to support it using chi-squared calculations and other statistical measurements of how well the data fits the hypothesis. I hadn't taken any statistics courses, so it seemed totally opaque and impossible to me to do this. I could never figure out what equation to use, or how to do it. I could follow step by step in the workbook and if I did so I would get a fine grade, but I was literally looking at the equations every 3 seconds as I worked the problem out. Anyway, I looked up the stuff in a statistics text, read the proofs and explanations of all the things I needed to understand, and suddenly it all made sense at once and I never had to refer back to anything. Once it 'clicks' everything is clear, like someone turned the light on in a dark room, before it 'clicks' I feel like I am suffocating.
Anecdote: In physics class (I was a physics major for awhile, so it was a 'real' physics class) there was what I guess was a very complex problem. The professor posed the problem and asked 'how do we solve this', and I raised my hand and told him the integral. It took me about 10 seconds or so f talking to say the entire equation. It blew everyone's mind, but it was really obvious if you could see it. I don't mean to brag, but if I was trying to think it through like socrates in a dialog I would have taken a week.