The skipping of beacon intervals is called PS-POLL and is why I said 2mA otherwise it is closer to 100mA -- which for example is what TI's CC3000 module burns since it doesn't have PS-POLL.
I agree that there are alternative ways to wake up WiFi. They said at one point in HN that they were thinking of having WiFi wake up when you knock. The problem with this is that the experience is markedly different from what they're advertising to users.
You'd pull out your phone, bring up the app, hit unlock, then knock on the door, wait for WiFi to turn on, associate with access point, get to cloud, "see" the unlock command and then unlock the door. That's easily 7-10 seconds at best.
Screw that. I'll just take out my key.
Giving WiFi long life by keeping it off is relatively easy. Making it instantly responsive, which is what anyone using the lock would expect, is impossible at the quoted battery life.
It is kind of like selling a car saying it'll get 500mpg but not telling the buyers that you only get that if you go say 10mph.
As well, their software learns your habits over time and can be awake when it expects you to arrive.
These tricks and others will improve over time. Enough to where it's more than an acceptable experience for many, if not for you.
It's definitely not the same experience though. I live in a condo and have the lockitron on my unit's door. I have the choice between opening the lockitron app in the elevator and send the unlock signal via wifi, but that means I'll need to knock for sure. Or I could wait until the elevator gets there and try to unlock, and if i'm really lucky it will be via BLE and unlock instantly, but generally the BLE hasn't managed to connect yet and I get no indicator, so I send the command to early and I need to knock anyway.
Speed is such a critical factor here. It doesn't take that long to pull your keys out, and it feels more awkward to stand and wait at your own front door than it does to fumble with the keys for a while. If I'm carrying groceries or a baby, then Lockitron has the potential to make things easier, but currently I still need to fiddle with my phone for a while (maybe in the elevator, but still) and knock so it doesn't really feel easier than using a key.
Plus, locks are trivially pickable, so it's not like they stop someone that wants to break into your house from breaking into your house.
Neither matters though, because a big purpose of locks is to show that you took reasonable precautions in order for your insurance to be valid. (YMMV, IANAL, etc. but that's the case here.)
(I've never used a pick gun, but I hear that makes it even easier. Especially for locks that don't have any particular anti-picking features, like the majority of locks on people's homes.)
You're totally correct that always-on-instant-unlock feature is a fool's errand as that would mandate always-on Wifi, spelling death for battery life.
I think one feasible method is sleeping the Wifi and using an external input (like a button or a "knock" sensor) that wakes up the Wifi, tells the chip to check the server for updated lock state, and then go back to sleep. I've played around with capacitive sensing on a door handle to wake up the Wifi and check the server as soon as someone lays hands on the door. Cap sensing is also incredibly low power so it had minimal impact on battery life.
This of course introduces all kinds of problems, but if Wifi is absolutely necessary, then this is one solution.
Either that, or wake up to poll Wifi every 5, 10, 15 minutes (destroying instant lock/unlock)