Re:Are Uber and Lyft responsible for reducing DUIs?
by beaner on Sunday July 13, 2014 @05:44PM
(#8028632)
I think his point is simply that if the regulation limiting the number of cabs had not been in place, DUIs would have already been reduced due to that. It's not anything about how uber of lyft work in particular that is contributing to the positive affect, just the increased ability to hitch a ride. So it sounds like you are not actually disagreeing with him, other than for the fact that uber/lyft deserve any sort of credit for it.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Are Uber and Lyft responsible for reducing DUIs?
by robg on Sunday July 13, 2014 @06:18PM
(#8028718)
That's a hypothetical ("if the regulation limiting the number of cabs had not been in place") made real exactly by Uber/Lyft. Let me put it this way:
Hypothesis: Too few cabs mean more DUIs
Experiment: Add more "cabs"
Expected Result: More cabs will lead to fewer DUIs
Uber/Lyft is the Experiment. The argument about other Experiments is irrelevant. Sure, less regulation could mean more cabs. But that wasn't the Experiment.
That counter argument is logically equivalent to saying "Drones, Blimps, Automated Cars all could have been cabs. There's nothing special about Uber/Lyft". There the difference is between a hypothetical and an actual result.
I'd also add that Uber offers far more than just "More cabs". It offers more safety, convenience, and trust. The driver is known, the car arrives when you are ready, and you don't have to haggle about not using cash.
Re:Are Uber and Lyft responsible for reducing DUIs?
by eruditely on Sunday July 13, 2014 @06:00PM
(#8028667)
And unfortunately for him the original point is quite cogent, and that no doubt Uber/Lyft should be given credit, for the bypassed regulations that negatively affect the world and thus have reduced total DUI's and deaths.
Re:Are Uber and Lyft responsible for reducing DUIs?
by robg on Sunday July 13, 2014 @06:22PM
(#8028732)
In fact, I'd argue that because Uber/Lyft are more trustworthy than traditional cabs, the result on DUIs is more robust. Using Uber is far safer for a drunk person than trying to hail a taxi, haggle with a driver, and hope you make it home.