Re:Popcorntime is leaving GitHub
by _ak on Sunday July 13, 2014 @11:31AM
(#8027602)
Well, you can, but that would be fraudulent. But whoever you sent the DMCA takedown notice to, it's not their concern and not their duty to check whether you're the rightful copyright holder or not.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Does this mean that someone could take down all of github by sending (fraudulent) DMCA takedown notices for every single repo (from some fake return address)?
And then it would then be incumbent on the users to fight that?
No. The main requirement for a DMCA request to be valid is that it come from a real entity. If you sent them with a fake return address they wouldn't be valid DMCA requests anymore.
That said, yes the DMCA can be abused. The check against that is the same check that exists against other kinds of fraud: it's illegal.
Re:Popcorntime is leaving GitHub
by stefan_kendall3 on Sunday July 13, 2014 @11:58AM
(#8027692)
Yes. But in that case, GitHub would likely fight an obviously fraudulent copyright claim, as it would wreck their business.
They're not hurt at all by popcorntime going down.