Re:Ask HN: What language do you think in?
by mbrubeck on Thursday September 03, 2009 @12:07PM
(#802747)
It's perfectly possible to express solutions at a high level without much regard for formal semantics. Knuth's The Art of Computer Programming expresses most of its algorithms in a combination of informal English and ad-hoc pseudocode. It's usually not difficult to translate them into languages with semantics varying from machine code to Haskell.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
I didn't say "formal semantics", I said "fixed semantics", as in "something you understand and can apply consistently within a context". Within the context of a single code-fragment, the semantics are not changing. They might change from example to example, but that's perfectly reasonable.
My assertion is that when people say "I think in pseudo-code", they actually mean "an idealised version of language X", where language X is some paradigm or language they understand well.
I just wrote a blog post about this very subject, based on the flood of comments (shameless self-promotion follows):