News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Kickstarter project spent $3.5M to finish a prototype and... by alexnking on Thursday July 10, 2014 @09:03PM (#8018355)
In my opinion, Kickstarter projects should not be legally obligated to deliver hardware rewards. We already have something just like that called "stores" and "preorders". I want to fund projects where the creators don't need to be 100% sure their idea will work before having the means to try it out. And I certainly don't want people to be able to sue those creators if it doesn't work out.
Re:Kickstarter project spent $3.5M to finish a prototype and... by dragonwriter on Thursday July 10, 2014 @09:14PM (#8018382)
> In my opinion, Kickstarter projects should not be legally obligated to deliver hardware rewards.

There's an easy way around that for projects, don't offer the output of the project as a reward for backing it.

> I want to fund projects where the creators don't need to be 100% sure their idea will work before having the means to try it out.

Okay, back projects where the creators don't offer the output of the project as the reward for backing it. (Or, projects where the development is already done, and the Kickstarter is just being done for initial production costs, so the product isn't speculative.)

> And I certainly don't want people to be able to sue those creators if it doesn't work out.

The only reason people could sue the creators is if the creators offered something in exchange for money, received the money, and didn't deliver as promised.

The creators are in full control of what they offer as rewards. It seems to me that the problem is that some people want creators to be able to use the promise of a product they don't know that they can produce as inducement for people to give money, but not be obligated to actually follow through.

Re:Kickstarter project spent $3.5M to finish a prototype and... by jacalata on Thursday July 10, 2014 @10:21PM (#8018572)
This project advertised itself as having all the development finished and only needing pre-order cash to kick off the manufacturing, so that's not really a good guide:

The "Designs" are complete, patents filed, component suppliers selected, the manufacturing process is defined, the CM [contract manufacturer] chosen so all we need is your support in this project as we size the first myIDkey production run and ship product in September 2013. Please make a pledge and receive your myIDkey!

Re:Kickstarter project spent $3.5M to finish a prototype and... by saraid216 on Thursday July 10, 2014 @09:37PM (#8018447)
Why only hardware rewards?