edit : I can't reply to you, but re-read what I said. I am making the point that I believe Land of Lisp to be for people coming from other languages, whereas I think that "learn X the hard way" is better for people new to programming altogether.
The parent of my reply is pointing out to zedshaw that "Land of Lisp" is a good beginners book. I am adding that it's my opinion that it's a good "beginner at lisp" book, and not an overall "good-for-beginner-programmers" book.
Though, I have absolutely nothing to back up my thought on this. Would be curious to see any studies or other such on these thoughts.
Also, apologies for the edit. My main thought was more for the informal nature of Land of Lisp. That is, it isn't "high theory" written for experts, nor is it written for kids.
To quote from the book page:
Along the way you’ll create (and play) games like Wizard
Adventure, a text adventure with a whiskey-soaked twist,
and Grand Theft Wumpus, the most violent version of Hunt
the Wumpus the world has ever seen.
http://www.nostarch.com/lisp.htm#tocIf someone would like to argue that it does not have a "game approach", I would like to see the specific reasoning as to why.
> The Little LISPer is based on lecture notes from a two-week ``quickie'' introduction to Lisp for students with no previous programming experience and an admitted dislike for anything quantitative. Many of these students were preparing for careers in public affairs.
I don't know exactly what that means, but it sounds university-level?
All the examples are about food, and there's cartoons littered throughout. There's a bunch of books that seem to be of that tone (Learn you a Haskell, Land of Lisp, Realm of Racket, Learn You Some Erlang), and I found myself instinctively recoiling from all of them (I haven't read the Erlang book, but it seems very much in that style).
I think it's important to have lots of different styles of books for learning a language, because I think different people respond better to different approaches, but selfishly, I wish every language had an equivalent to "ANSI Common Lisp" (by this site's benefactor emeritus) and Real World Haskell. I am also a big fan of the way Zed chose to lay out his books.
The intro is a little bit copied but it's fine since he is keeping to the idea and the "rules" I have, but could be nicer if it was in his own voice more. Who knows, maybe he does write like me a lot or he's just ultra inspired.
The big reason I say people should use their own words, apart from copyright, is that if you're writing one of these books for a programming language you love then your words will express that better. You'll say things that come from your community and culture, and you'll give away a sense of what you like about that language. When people copy what I say the prose comes out obviously not by them and not for that language.
Anyway, this is pretty cool and I hope he works on it some more.