Are you certain you get no benefits as a temporary worker? I am looking into getting my wife non-permanent-residency in the U.S. One part of this is me proving, through prior tax filings, that I live well above the poverty level for a family of 3. The reason for this is once she is here, she can file for welfare and such. So apparently, a new resident, even non-permanent does have some social benefits: welfare, emergency health care, etc.
The tax structure is complex, uneven, and government spending is not well controlled. I feel that if we fix issues like we are trying to do with offshore banking, we can get to the next part, which is determining more fair taxation. So long as there are ways out for some, there is not enough force to fix tax fairness issues.
So should we:
A - not collect those social taxes until you complete the process and then ask for years of back taxes once you become a citizen?
B - not collect at all and treat them as temporary workers that we can throw out at will with no intention if letting them become citizens?
C - collect the taxes and let them have it back if you leave and don't finish the process of becoming a citizen?
There are other choices, but that should show their are problems with any way we choose.
I guess when that happens, china/india will go to war against U.S. for sovereign power over taxation.
However, this is just their stated issue. The real reasons are much larger than this one taxable interest.
If Swiss citizens (or any other doing biz with this "neutral" country) don't want to pay U.S. taxes, they can buy and sell property in Switzerland or some other country that doesn't mind its citizens carrying the tax burden for non-citizens.