It seems clear to me that someone who isn't deriving any benefit from the "protections" of the US government shouldn't be required to pay for those protections. Otherwise, it really is just a protection racket.
So when you say "protections". Well, if I'm not living in the U.S. "right now" I'm not right now receiving protections, right? Not really. I am. I can go home anytime I want if things get too tough for me in China. I have the safety of knowing their are local police and fire departments in my home town protecting my house, for example, the things that non-citizens don't want to pay taxes to help support.
Even if I were living in the U.S. right now, I wouldn't be pulling money from Social Security or other forms of aid. But the "protections" are their whether I'm currently using them or not.
To be sure, much of the reason we have consul services in other countries is not just for benefit of visiting U.S. citizens. We also pay fees when we use such services. Consuls/Embassies exist for business development and foreign policy management as well. A U.S. citizen that has never left the U.S. benefits from those services indirectly.
I don't get it. Why would non-citizens not want to pay for police and fire-trucks? Don't you pay for those essential services in China, or if you do, do you consider those an unnecessary burden there?
In China, I pay taxes on my home, and the gov is expected to use some of this money to protect my home there. I'm not being double taxed, I have two homes and pay for each in their respective countries.
I'm saying that the person has no home in the USA, no nothing. But the USA still taxes income made overseas. Heck, even if this hypothetical person renounces his citizenship, they continue to take the taxes for another ten years!
The reason people make the choice is because they want the benefits they may get from coming to the U.S. I realize it is too hard for many that come to the U.S. to become citizens; we need to fix that problem. Our immigration strategies are not clear and makes immigrants pay on both ends of the deal.
But really, if you want to come to the U.S., suck out some wealth, and then say "so long", well, you'll get what's coming to you.
They may be fairly unique in doing so, but the US is a fairly unique country in terms of percentage of the global economy. Other countries may have no tax in order to entice more investment, the US does not have to do that. If you don't want to pay the taxes, don't invest in the US economy.
the things they mentioned, US Treasuries, stock in US companies ARE benefiting from the US gov't protection
The companies that our hypothetical expat owns the stock in already paid corporate income taxes for their own protection. Why should he pay again for it?
Really, the questions here are
* Should the US government be able to dictate the laws of foreign lands, in order to satisfy its own choice of tax regime?
* Should the US government be able to dictate that foreign corporations provide data to the US, forcing those foreign corporations to bear the costs for enforcing the American tax regime?
No they should not. But this is not what's happening here. The transactions originated in the U.S. by and through U.S. entities.
* Should the US government be able to dictate that foreign corporations provide data to the US, forcing those foreign corporations to bear the costs for enforcing the American tax regime?
Again, that's not what's happening here. When UBS or any other foreign bank operates in the U.S., it is incorporated as a U.S. entity and must follow U.S. laws. UBS and such have chose to say "oh, those customers we acquired in the U.S., well, that data is back in Switzerland, and we have strict privacy laws there, so no can do". Sorry, but the transactions originated in the U.S. through the U.S. operating entity, Swiss laws have no say here.
These banks have gotten off incredibly light. The U.S. has plenty of existing laws on the books to allow them to seize the assets of the entire bank for their illegal behavior. The only reason they did not is because seizing Swiss banks would have unknowable repercussions from global elite.
Now, I know next to nothing about international inheritance and estate tax policy, but I'd have to assume many, many other nations have identical policies, no?