In contrast to that, bicyclist lawlessness doesn't even rate. But bicycle lawlessness hasn't been folded into the accepted comfortable fuzzy border around lawfulness so every instance is a horrid and unique crime against the sanctity of the law and the foundations of civil society.
Edit: both bicyclist and motorist lawlessness is problematic. But the existence of either does not somehow damn the entire population of bicyclists or motorists. There are good motorists and bad motorists as there are good cyclists and bad cyclists. As mentioned above, folks who rail against the universal lawlessness of cyclists are focusing on one of the least serious dangers on the road.
People complain about these infractions all the time. All the time. Just because something is "normal" doesn't mean people are happy with it.
In Idaho, bicyclists are not required to stop at stop signs.
The elephant in the room is speeding. Speeding is responsible for ~30% of all road fatalities, yet is universally condoned on American roads. Drivers do not understand how hypocritical they are when they complain about bicyclists disobeying road rules while they themselves are speeding.
"Speeding is reported in the Fatality Analysis Reporting System (FARS) as a driver-level attribute that combines 'driving too fast for conditions' or 'in excess of posted speed limit.'" [2]
Note that, in multi-vechicle accidents, only one party needs to have been speeding for the accident to be considered "speeding related". The 30% figure quoted also seems to vary quite a bit depending on the data you look at:
"The percentage of all crashes that were speeding-related (DTFFC or EPSL) varied considerably among the States, from about 6 percent to about 20 percent of all crashes" (ibid)
The NHTSA distinguishes between two types of speeding:
1) Exceeding Posted Speed Limit (EPSL)
2) Driving Too Fast For Conditions (DTFFC)
The former simply occurs whenever one's speed is greater than the posted maximum. The latter is a subjective call by the police officer, etc investigating the case and factors in road, traffic, and weather conditions.
The NHTSA has found (ibid) that about half of speeding-related fatal crashes occur for EPSL (55%) and the other half for DTFFC (45%). For speeding-related crashes that result in injuries, the respective ratios are 26% and 74% (ibid). The same source mentions that
"The relative proportion of crashes that occurred on the curved sections of the road was much higher in speeding-related (DTFFC or EPSL) crashes"
which suggests that many of these accidents were actually caused by either some form of driver inattention or adverse weather affecting road conditions, and that speeding was a contributing factor in the accident (i.e. less ability to correct for an unexpected event) but not the sole cause. Since driver inattention is almost impossible to prove absent records of an untimely text message or tweet, it's likely that the true causes of most of these accidents (most likely driver inattention or overly agressive driving) go unreported and are instead attributed to the only measurable data point that can be discerned: speeding.
That's not true. First, "speeding related" is not synonymous with "caused by speeding". Second, the data that relates to "speeding related" crashes has a significant overlap with "alcohol related crashes". If you exclude the "alcohol related" crashes from the total, you'll find that percentage drops quite a bit.
Which, personally, I think is completely reasonable. Constantly stopping and pushing off again adds a huge amount of effort to a ride, and a cyclist has plenty of incentive to look before rolling through an intersection.
We also have 30 years of data from Idaho which allows cyclists to treat stop signs as yields: "Idaho bicycle-collision statistics confirm that the Idaho law has resulted in no discernible increase in injuries or fatalities to bicyclists."
http://btaoregon.org/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/hb2690-idaho...
Do you think this would be the case if applied to cars?
A bike can stop in far shorter distances than a car can (and will be travelling at a lower speed in the first place).
Bikes are also slower to accelerate than a car. Allowing a bike to maintain more of its momentum gets it through the intersection quicker, especially on any kind of uphill grade.
Anecdotal, perhaps, but I know that my personal experience has been that the combination of those two things means that I'm evaluating whether it's safe for me to pass through an intersection and making the decision much sooner on a bike than I would in a car where the assumption is I need to mostly stop because I may not be able to otherwise.
Of course, in a world where everybody is free to do rolling stops at whatever speed they feel comfortable with, the real issue is that bicycles have a greater incentive to slow down at intersections compared to drivers since the costs of being wrong about one's ability to do a rolling stop are much greater for the cyclist. A cyclist should also be more aware of their surroundings since they are not sitting in a metal and glass box with the radio on.
Also the car needs to use even more energy to get moving again so this would have financial/environmental benefits too.
Every subdivision thinks they need a 3 way stop at the entrance, so they start complaining and eventually the local government caves and installs one because it's relatively cheap to install a few signs (and it's easier to ignore the traffic engineer who says it's unnecessary than the dozens of people who live in the subdivision)
Pedestrians crossing at a stop sign have to yield to vehicular traffic, no?
And advocating the Idaho Stop isn't advocating for cyclists to blow through at full clip. Stop signs are treated as yields and have to be slowed for, and stop lights are treated as motor vehicles treat stop signs, requiring a full stop.
I'm a pedestrian and in the crosswalk. A cyclist is speeding toward me and doesn't stop. They either swerve around me or make me jump out of their way. A woman was killed last year in SF when she was hit by a cyclist in the crosswalk (she had the right of way, not crossing against the light).
So, even when there are consequences, cyclists act horribly.
You give one example of a pedestrian killed by a cyclist in SF last year. Also last year, 21 pedestrians and 4 cyclists were killed by cars[0].
That's still not a fair statistic because there are far more cars than bikes. So in 2012, 1.14 people were killed by cars in the US per 100 million miles driven[1].
I can't find similar bike stats for the US, but in the UK there are about 3.7 cyclist deaths per 100 million miles. How many of those deaths were caused by cyclists, and how many were caused by cars?
[0] http://www.sfgate.com/bayarea/article/Streets-of-S-F-a-road-...
[1] http://www.iihs.org/iihs/topics/t/general-statistics/fatalit...
Yes, on occasion cyclists stop for me when I'm in the crosswalk, but it's the exception.
I quoted information about cyclists, because you know, I was replying to a comment about cyclists.
The route I walk is heavily trafficked by cars and bikes, so the comparison is a fair one.
The irresponsible cyclist who killed a woman is just that--irresponsible and reckless. This is orthogonal to the fact that he was on a bike at the time.
http://www.sfgate.com/crime/article/Family-of-bicyclist-s-vi...
As this article abundandtly points out, the greatest cause for injury and death (you know, what we created traffic laws for) are cars. Hence, this is where enforcement needs to happen.
It's actually unreasonable to expect drivers or cyclists to obey traffic laws that have no sound basis. Many stop signs are in place because they're misused for speed control, or are installed in places where a yield sign would suffice, or they're in place at a T-intersection where it's plainly obvious that there's no traffic to yield to, and so on.
What we really need is remove a lot of stop signs and replace them with yield signs. The only intersections where they should stay in place is where visibility of oncoming or cross traffic is limited.
EDIT: I wouldn't wait excessively long, of course, only if it were a close call, same as with a pedestrian. Common sense.
Wow, apparently exercising common sense, being appropriately cautious, and not being angry at cyclists is downvote-worthy. It's all about the rules here I guess, despite many studies pointing out otherwise.
As a cyclist, this is one of the more annoying things I have to deal with. In the example you mention, I would expect you to proceed before I actually reach the intersection. Now, instead of slowing down and then proceeding through the intersection (after you've gone), I have to come to a stop and wait for you to proceed before I can go.
A cyclist knows that there is most likely no consequence for running a stop sign, so even if it is technically illegal, there's no incentive for them to stop. If motorists could get away with running stop signs just as easily, they would do the same. It's unreasonable to expect people to act contrary to their incentives.
We need to agree on what the law is, and enforce it accordingly. Maybe it doesn't make sense for cyclists to obey the same set of traffic signals as motorists; if that is the case then we need to explicitly say so.
This business where some people obey traffic signals and other don't needs to stop. That is the responsibility of city government and law enforcement.