If "the good old days" were really that good, why have women been almost intentionally excluded from IT until relatively recently? Do you mean "good" for people in general, or "good" for you?
When you say "we are being invaded," who is "we"? White men? People who are already "in"? More importantly, who is doing the invading? If women say "hey, these are small, tacitly accepted things in tech culture that make people uncomfortable," do you seriously think that statement is persecuting you? They're not trying to control your thoughts, they're trying to get you to be less of an asshole.
I have never excluded women. Also IT, tech, hackers are not interchangeable terms.
>Do you mean "good" for people in general, or "good" for you?
I meant good for hackers. People with a certain world view, goals and sense of humor.
>When you say "we are being invaded," who is "we"?
Again, hackers. We never cared for race nor sexuality.
>who is doing the invading?
Control freaks.
>They're not trying to control your thoughts, they're trying to get you to be less of an asshole.
If anything, this rules make it easier to be an asshole.
If someone says "hey, we should work on addressing this sexism," and the response is, "be quiet, there isn't any sexism, you just hate fun," that seems pretty stinking sexist, doesn't it? Dismissing someone's concerns by saying they aren't real doesn't address the concerns, it just sweeps them under the rug because they aren't perceived as being important enough to give a shit about.
If some group has evolved office slang that includes saying "Quit being a ginger" to people who make dumb mistakes, and then that group hires some redheaded dude, wouldn't it be within his rights to say "hey guys, it's kind of weird to use 'ginger' as a euphemism for 'dumbass'"? Yeah, maybe he's "invading" and stepping on the group's ability to insult people at the expense of other groups, but it doesn't mean he's wrong.
Conveniently, you've also accurately described what happens when someone expresses concern about negative side effects of new social rules.
No.
Replace sexism with unicorns and reread your premise.
If somebody says, "hey, this is some bad sexism," that's a lousy argument, because it's a vague statement that can't be proven either way. You could respond with "no it isn't, shhh" and it would be just as reasonable a rebuttal as any other.
But if someone says "these are things I think contribute to an unnecessarily exclusionary environment, here's why it should change," then I think it's disingenuous to just say "meh, no" without addressing the concerns. It's basically someone saying, "I think my opinions are being written off without being properly discussed," and responding with "That's not true, discussion over, it's written off." There's got to at least be a discussion, no?
No, it isn't.
If you believe you have an actionable claim, bring it to court.
If you don't (and you know that you don't) you have no right to shame and defame people, while hiding behind some bullshit policy that prevents them from defending themselves.
They're either not capable or find it uninteresting, often both at the same time.
by whom?
>The culture we used to have didn't cared about isms or whatever you want to call them.
When? Depending how far back you go, The hacker culture attracted a very specific type of person. It was self-selective, so they themselves had similar cultural norms.
Today is very different. Hackers are more diverse, thus these issues come to light.
This brings us back to:
> Now we are being invaded.
There are going to be growing pains, but in the end, diversity is a good thing, right?
Or is this all an issue about degree?
Not sure, people who care more about a narrative of justice than technical hacks.
>When? Depending how far back you go, The hacker culture attracted a very specific type of person. It was self-selective, so they themselves had similar cultural norms.
I guess that the startup scene made us popular, which tends to attract the sort of people who like guidelines, rules and control.
> There are going to be growing pains, but in the end, diversity is a good thing, right?
I just do not see why we need rules. Specially rules we are not expected to bend.
This reads like a 4chan teenager's manifesto. Alright, a bunch of nerds in their basements who are just so edgy and can say whatever they want. Badass! Well, you might be pleased to know that you're totally free to carry on the misanthropy club in plenty of areas of the internet. But here on Hacker News, and apparently especially at Hacker School, a lot of people that are actually coming from within the culture would like to see some change.
When I read this article, I too was annoyed. I felt it was over the top, way too politically correct. But then I read the comments here, and it's basically all these people coming out of the woodwork and vaulting right over the spirit of understanding in their haste to defend their right to be acerbic assholes.
They're not trying to silence you, they're just trying to implement guidelines that foster inclusion and collaboration. Is that really so awful?
How can you talk that way and the next moment talk about fostering inclusion?
Now we are being invaded. We, like every other culture in the world, are ask to not use certain language and not have certain thoughts. If we do not comply, we are heretics. Only they don't use that term, they rather use some ism.
The wheel of history is repeating. The control freaks still want to control, they just changed one set of sins for another.