I'm not sure the 11% using a 5 year old version (on some 5 year old phone?) is exactly the kind of people that BUY apps...
To be honest, if you are indie developer and you don't have very aggressive IAP like Clash of Clans or Throne Rush, there is no money from people that buy apps. I've seen cool indie games like TripleTown having trouble monetizing. I bet one could make more money from Ads (although I hate ads, I hate them less than whale-catching-IAPs).
People using old devices can still click ads.
I use 2.3.3 as the lowest supported version, since most important features were introduced with 2.3.3. At least, I don't know any reason to require 4.0 to be minimum, so why lose 11% of your users. I was curious if OP used some important feature that would require 4.0.